Will you be buying the new edition of TWTM?

[Michelle T]

Yes

[kalanamak]

I look at the reviews on how "different" it is or isn't. If the only major difference is resources, well, I feel rather surrounded and mugged by resources already.

[Avila]

I have the first one, so it is time for an update, I think!

[Karen sn]

I'm trying to phrase this nicely...

Why?

 

What has been updated to such a degree that it warrants another book?

I agree with the other poster who is already in a sea of curricculum choices, so if that's the only update.....

 

Maybe I am just jaded because of all the updates/new edition text books from high school and college, but to me - new isn't always better but is most often costly.

[Lovedtodeath]

I think it would depend on the age of my DC. Since we are just starting, and some of the current suggestions are out of print, I could use the updated suggestions.

[TN Mama]

I voted other because I'm planning on purchasing, but have not yet pre-ordered.

 

I don't own a copy yet, but I feel like I have since I've checked the revised version out of the library so often.

[TraceyS/FL]

Yes. At some point... but i'm not sure when i'll be able to budget wise.

[Aubrey]

Probably, but we'll wait till $ is more available.

 

My reasons?

 

1. To support something I believe in.

 

2. To have an updated copy. I read the 1st ed at the library when I was pg w/ #1 & waited to buy it used because I couldn't afford it. A couple of yrs ago, I bought the 2nd ed new. It was less expensive, it had the SOTW suggestions, & again, I wanted to show support.

 

3. I have a weird thing about owning more than 1 copy of books I really like.

 

4. To have enough copies to loan out. My 2nd ed is out right now because it can be replaced if nec. My 1st ed stays home. :D

[Apiphobic]

No, we've actually gravitated to different materials and a different outlook on our homeschooling method. So, while we may use some of the ideas from wtm, our main homeschooling choices aren't in-synch with wtm and its precepts. Hence the recent spate of selling-mania.

Edited February 8, 2009 by Apiphobic

[Robin M]

Definitely. I've practically worn out the spine on my book. I think it will great to see what has been updated or what is new. I can't wait.

[Jumping In Puddles]

I'll check it out at the library at first but I may end up buying it. I recently checked out the second edition from the library so I can refresh my memory.

[bettyandbob]

I have the old old edition. You know the first one. I've looked at my neighbor's second edition. I might look at the third, but no rush.

[Crissy]

No. I have the original and the second editions, and I feel very comfortable with our homeschooling style.

[nukeswife]

I'm not sure yet. I don't use the 2nd edition I have now other than for reference if I'm not sure about where to go next etc and need ideas, but we're not following it very tightly so I'm not sure.

[cathmom]

I have the original edition, autographed by Jessie Wise. At some point I might buy the new edition, but with money so tight, I don't want to buy something I already have! I'd rather buy FLL or WWE.

[Parrothead]

Yes, I'll buy it new, but not until it is actually in the stores. I hate doing the pre-order thing.

[kat19]

I voted other.

I don't have it pre-ordered but I plan on buying it :001_smile:

[Basketmaker Amy]

I love my current (signed by Susan) copy!

[GreenKitty]

Are their any major differences between the two?

[FO4UR]

I have the old, old edition. I voted not buying a new one b/c my old book is just fine. I may change my mind, but as of now I know what resources I'm buying.

 

I am curious to see the new recommendations, so I will be spending some time at Barnes and Noble when it comes out.....and will probably put it back on my wishlist....:tongue_smilie:

[Moni]

There's another edition of TWTM coming out? ? ? :glare:

 

That's new to me...;)

 

:seeya:

[G5052]

and also involved in Classical Conservations. I'll check it out from the library and then decide if I need my own copy.

[Tree House Academy]

I own the revised version and will not be buying the new version.

[Tracey in TX]

Yes, but haven't ordered it yet. TWMT is the most used book I've ever owned. It's falling apart at the seams quite literally. I've purchased others to pass out. Just don't have the same love as my copy--highlighted, written in, marked up, crossed out, and generally just loved! :)

[PinkInTheBlue]

Yes, but I don't have it on preorder.

[Sharon H in IL]

I want to send some money SWB's way. :D

 

So although I don't have it on pre-order, I will definitely be buying it. I need to step up the pace for my older son's education, and I want to know all the latest suggestions for curricula.

[Holly IN]

I voted other because I plan on getting it but haven't preordered yet.

 

Holly

[Jenny in Florida]

However, as our "classical" style has developed, I've found I don't use too many of the recommended resources, preferring instead to source or create my own. So, since we've found an approach that works for us, I'm not really buying ANY new guidebooks.

 

I would love to skim it, though. So, I may check it out of the library at some point.

[Melissa in Australia]

I will buy the new book. but I haven't pre ordered

[Storm Bay]

Yes, but it's NOT on preorder--I'm waiting until I have a book budget again. Then I'll donate my first edition one to the library if they would like another copy.

[sweetfeet]

No. I bought a 99 edition after reading the 04 edition. I actually prefer the 99 edition because it tells you how to set up subjects without relying heavily on curriculum. The 04 edition seemed like a parade of recommendations, which I appreciated, but I feel like knowing how and why they recommend a curriculum and how it should be set up is of more use to me.

[Barb_]

I voted other because I've not made a decision yet. I plan to flip through it at the bookstore to decide whether I feel the need to purchase another one. I already own the first two editions, so I probably won't.

 

Barb

[KidsHappen]

Yes, I will be buying it as my 2nd ed. is falling apart. I also like to support Susan and this site.

[Jen in PA]

I voted other because I will be buying it in the near future, but haven't bothered to preorder. I don't own a copy, but I'm wearing out the library's copy! I figure I'll buy the new one, and its resource list will be useful for the next several years, at least enough to get both kids through the grammar stage.

[Night Elf]

Chose other because I will definitely buy it but see no reason to pre-order it. I support SWB and Peace Hill Press. :)

[WTMindy]

Chose other because I will definitely buy it but see no reason to pre-order it. I support SWB and Peace Hill Press. :)

 

That is exactly my post!! I ALWAYS buy directly from Peace Hill whenever I can. I'm looking forward to it because I can't find my 2nd edition right now!!

[Colleen]

I enjoy having WTM on hand for a reference, but I don't adhere to many of its suggestions. Even if I did, I doubt I'd buy the latest edition.

[jkwynn]

I will be buying it.

 

This is our first year of homeschool and I don't have a copy yet because I'm waiting on the new edition.

 

I have been using the older ones from the library (heavily, hehe) and feel like I have them almost memorized, but look forward to the new version, as well.

[lionfamily1999]

I will, but it has to wait. I'm not planning on buying it used, it's just not in my budget for now.

[Desert Rat]

I'll check for differences from a library copy and if anything is pertinent to our situation I'll pencil them in my loved and worn copy at home.

[Rhonda in TX]

They have it listed as "on order", so I was able to reserve it ahead of time. I'm number 3 on the list, so I'll get it right away. :)

[Susan Wise Bauer]

You know, the new editions will probably come out every five years or so...and they're not directed at folks who already HAVE an edition (although you're certainly more than welcome to buy one). The new editions are so that we don't have to answer fifteen million emails saying, "The book/s you recommended are out of print. What do you suggest instead?"

 

SWB

[anissarobert]

I had to check other. My dh is out of work, so it is not in the budget right now, but I will buy it when I can.

[wide eyes & laughter]

Yes, I'll buy it new, but not until it is actually in the stores. I hate doing the pre-order thing.

 

:iagree:

[lionfamily1999]

You know, the new editions will probably come out every five years or so...and they're not directed at folks who already HAVE an edition (although you're certainly more than welcome to buy one). The new editions are so that we don't have to answer fifteen million emails saying, "The book/s you recommended are out of print. What do you suggest instead?"

 

SWB

Thanks! I'll stick with my new old version, then.

[JumpedIntoTheDeepEndFirst]

Yes, because I'd be sending those emails about out of print books. I'll probably keep the dogeared old copy too though.

[Sarah CB]

I lied in my poll answer. I said I have already pre-ordered when I haven't. But, I am planning to pre-order as soon as I get around to it and I'll definitely be buying the new edition. I had one copy of the first edition and two copies of the second edition (one to loan out and I have no idea who has it now). I plan to buy at least one copy of the new edition; maybe more.

[JenniferB]

I will probably order a new copy, not sure if I'll wait until a used one is available, but maybe. I'm not sure how many editions there are, but I think I own the 1st edition, so I'd like to get the updates, someday.

[Guest Katia]

I voted Obligatory Other because next year will be my last homeschooling. It's my Baby and she's my last one.....so I don't really need another book, even though I *do* have both editions of TWTM. Guess they did the job!