Jump to content

Menu

Tree Change dolls--I think this is rather lovely


Chris in VA
 Share

Recommended Posts

 I've seen pictures of the dolls around but never the story about them.  I agree, it is lovely.   But I've never understood the appeal of the Bratz type dolls with their exaggerated features and makeup.   I seem to recall, years ago, a Barbie that was styled similarly to Bratz.  I don't remember the real name but I believe I called it "Streetwalker Barbie."  It caused me to stop buying anything ever in the Target toy aisle.  There may have been a loud meltdown involved too, but I am not sure.  I'm not usually a public meltdown person.

  • Like 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

The video does a good job of characterizing the artist as quite innocent of the business end of what she has started... but I think if her values really are where they seem to be (and I hope they are) we will see her producing tutorial videos, not just the dolls themselves as a high-end hand-crafted product.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Is it really that easy: just nail polish remover? I think I'd probably need patterns, instructions, and drawings, and advice of what kind of paints to buy and how to form a nice looking eye, and what shades make natural features look right. Maybe that's all second-nature to people who are already artistic. And what kind of clay (does it harden?)

 

Not that I really need to know. It's just that I don't think someone like me could do it well without some detailed help, and I don't think I'm alone in that.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Yeah, I was thinking that having her say what sort of paint she uses in NZ might not be particularly helpful for those of us living elsewhere.

 

I like that she says on the tumblr that she hopes to inspire other people to be creative with old toys.  Dd and I were entranced by the whole thing, and a good deal of the charm was that she was reusing cast off items.  I think if a toy company manufactured these new we wouldn't have been so excited about them.

 

I've painted flower fairy faces on tiny little wooden beads; that experience showed me that patterns are somewhat ... superfluous when you're painting little faces on dolls.  You mostly have to have a steady hand and a willingness to screw up.  But it would be nice if she explained her process of what she paints first, then next, etc.  We were analyzing her choice of eye color, how she contours the nose, how she has experimented with mouth shapes.  We also discussed how the looser clothing works for the proportions of those particular dolls' bodies vs. heads.

 

(You know, I've often commented that I can't figure out literary analysis, but it occurs to me that analyzing crafting process seems easy peasy.  Huh. Is this what you guys do when you're looking at literature -- noticing how all the bits fit together, and how the author's process worked?) (Okay, that was a total digression, but I tend to read many of the threads here with my "homeschool mom" hat on regardless of the subject matter.)

  • Like 4
Link to comment
Share on other sites

The only thing I'd worry about is Mattel coming after her for using their plastic doll as the base.  

 

I think if she tries to sell them they could come after her, but other than that she is entitled to change the dolls she purchased.  At least I would think.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I have a friend on a homeschooling fb group that did this with her daughter today.  She had seen the video, she redid the face on one, her 7 yr old redid another one.  They had a great time and the little girl is thrilled with the new look the dolls have now.  I did not see this video until now and did not know what video she was referring to when she shared the pictures of the dolls she and her daughter did.  Neat idea, I hate those Brats dolls but you can usually find them for a quarter to $1 at the thrift shops.  I can see redoing them for my afterschool daycare.  They want some barbie type dolls but I do not want trashy looking ones there 

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

What a great story! Those dolls are fantastic. 

 

The appeal of Barbie and Bratz, is the plastic movable body. It's so much easier to accessorize and dress than other dolls. I can't stand them, so I've bought other dolls, but it's clearly not as much fun as her friend's dolls. 

 

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Those are fantastic! I vehemently HATE Barbies of any flavor. They are forbidden in my house. I am not ashamed to say I have trained dd to detest them, as well. These would be a great alternate for her. They remind me of Waldorf dolls or what Waldorf dolls might look like in Barbie-ish form. Wholesome.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest submarines

The video does a good job of characterizing the artist as quite innocent of the business end of what she has started... but I think if her values really are where they seem to be (and I hope they are) we will see her producing tutorial videos, not just the dolls themselves as a high-end hand-crafted product.

I don't understand the pressure on the artist to produce tutorials. If she wants to, sure, why not. But if she wants to make high-end hand-crafted dolls, it is wonderful too.

  • Like 4
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I feel a need to point out that I was a parent who allowed Barbie and Bratz dolls, yet I have two teenage dds who choose not to wear makeup and aren't big on their appearance. I took them both for makeovers and to buy makeup for their 13th birthdays but they are like me and just don't wear it. I've never had to veto clothes because they dress so modestly. It's really not the dolls or the toys. I feel it's much more about the relationships. My dds know those toys are just that and have no meaning in their actual lives (just as I did when I played with Barbies).

  • Like 5
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest submarines

I don't buy it that playing with a certain type of doll makes or breaks a girl's self esteem and core values. However, I find Bratz dolls so utterly visually repulsive, I could never get them for my girls. Thankfully my girls found them ugly. I would've bought them a Barbie if they asked, though. They never asked either, but my girls are not "doll" kids, the mostly have stuffed animals anyway.

 

I do wonder, though, what makes the dolls attractive to certain parents and children, and what kind of parents buy them and what kind of girls play with Bratz. I personally haven't met any, but mind you, I'm rotating in those "unworldly homeschooling" circles.

  • Like 3
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I feel a need to point out that I was a parent who allowed Barbie and Bratz dolls, yet I have two teenage dds who choose not to wear makeup and aren't big on their appearance. I took them both for makeovers and to buy makeup for their 13th birthdays but they are like me and just don't wear it. I've never had to veto clothes because they dress so modestly. It's really not the dolls or the toys. I feel it's much more about the relationships. My dds know those toys are just that and have no meaning in their actual lives (just as I did when I played with Barbies).

 

Hmmm interesting point. 

 

My experience with Barbies (Bratz just didn't happen to cross our path):

 

When I worked out how to be a Perfect Mother (i.e., before I had any children), I was definitely not going to allow Barbies. So we happily went ahead and didn't buy any, and none of the kids requested them. Then one day, my mother dug out an ancient box of Barbies that had been mine in the 1980s, and asked whether the kids might like to have them. My thought process went roughly like "No! Because feminism... ummm... actually... yes! because retro and nostalgia (and I'm too much of a tightwad to pass up something free)". The box of Barbies came home, not without some trepidation on my part.

 

The kids started playing with the dolls, and I peeked in to see how it was going. The Barbies had discarded their dressy clothing and were looking for jodhpurs. The girls were talking about the dolls' anatomy. Comments included "They are so thin. They must not get enough to eat." and "Look at their silly shaped feet! Don't they know that wearing high heels all the time causes damage?". Moreover, the play scenarios didn't include anything different from what the kids already did with stuffed toys. It seemed that the Barbies made no difference. 

 

It was quite interesting to see how Barbies had changed over the years, in appearance - more manga-like, for want of a better word -  and marketing - they are now cheap-ish toys aimed at little girls, whereas in my school days they were expensive and aimed at tweens (I still played with mine in 6th grade, and so did most girls I knew). I still don't like them much though.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 11 months later...

I don't like the Bratz dolls either. But I haven't paid close attention to them either. When she takes paint off their faces it becomes a lot more obvious how young the doll is-- the head to body size ratio is much more childlike than Barbies-- which makes it that much more horrifying that they painted up with so much make-up. Icky. I love how her new face paint makes them look more like little girls. I prefer that so much more than adult Barbies.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

 Share

×
×
  • Create New...