I think the difference here is that when you live in a potentially dangerous area, you know where you can safely travel and you know what places to avoid. A first-time vacationer doesn’t know any of that. The vacationer doesn’t know that if she’s safe at her hotel on Main Street and she travels two blocks north, she’ll be fine... but if she travels two blocks south, it’s a dangerous neighborhood and she probably shouldn’t go there. The locals might not need Lanny’s warning, but the average person on this forum who’s planning a vacation to Jamaica would probably really appreciate that he was thoughtful enough to start this thread. It could help her decide how much risk she and her family are willing to take, and if they decide they still want to schedule their trip, reading the warnings may help them as they look for the safest places to stay and the best modes of transportation to and from their hotels or resorts.