I had something similar happen to me. It involved a large stuffed turtle, with his stuffing coming out, that I laid on almost every day to read. Sure, it was junky, but it was well loved. Like the pp, it still makes me mad that my mom refused to see how special it was to me.
If you think your dc will be sad about it, then don't toss them. Let them help make the decisions and then pack some away for another day.