Everything is Illuminated is amazing. I keep a running log of all the movies we see, so here are just a few that got high marks. I enjoy offbeat, small, and some old movies as well...hopefully you will enjoy a few. Sylvia, Ordinary People, Rear Window, The Apartment, anything by Christopher Guest, Shattered Glass, Iris, Before Sunset, The Seventh Seal, The French Connection, Garden State, Danny Deckchair, Gaslight, The Barbarian Invasions,The Sting, The Sea Inside, The Upside of Anger, Off the Map, Mrs. Miniver, Proof, Winter Passing, Gosford Park, Alone in the Wilderness,10 Items or Less,....gosh I could go on and on. I also love The Office (british version) Spaced, all the Poirot series, House, Freaks and Geeks, and Arrested Development, Planet Earth, Blue Planet, and Boston Legal as far as TV series. I have logged over a 1000 movies, tv shows, and documentaries to this point...PM me in the future for further recs if these work out.