I REALLY, REALLY wanted to like it. I still have it b/c I want to like it.
BUT, it's boring (for us). My son would GROAN every time we got it out. It's a great program, but he didn't retain anything b/c we did it orally since he's writing phobic and it required a ton of writing. I do think it's a GREAT program, just not for us. I used it for 1/2 of 2nd and I have 3rd grade as well, but we're sticking with FLL after trying GWG.