If I had to choose I would pick Edward. Even though I would be reading and think how romantic he is and then I would think, eww, he is 100 years old and she is a baby in comparison. But he was so charismatic, and sparkly, and I am a sucker for the knight in shining armor.
Jacob irritated me. He knew what he was getting into and he would still go off and sulk.
Bella, is the most annoying person on the face of the planet. Whiny, selfish, just awful to the people around her.
That said, I did enjoy the brain candy while I was reading it.