Jump to content


What's with the ads?

Photo

How to "schedule" or "approach" AOPS Pre-Algebra?


22 replies to this topic

What's with the ads?

#1 JHLWTM

JHLWTM

    Just Visiting

  • Members
  • Pip
  • 280 posts

Posted 09 November 2017 - 01:06 AM

Hello Hive, 

Hoping that some of you who have been-there-and-done-that can provide some advice or examples of how you or your child used AOPS Pre-Alg.

 

DD9 is finishing up Beast 5D in the next 2 weeks. She has worked through Beast largely on her own. I step in if she is having trouble with the problems, but for the most part she uses it on a self-teaching model.  She aims to complete roughly 2 pages out of the WB each day. If there are lots of star/ double star problems, she might do only one page.

 

Looking now at AOPS Pre-Alg (yikes, I know I'm late to the game - I didn't think she's finish 5D so soon), I'm not sure how to help her structure her approach to each chapter. I would love to have her to continue to "self-teach" from the text as much as possible (she's developed confidence, independence and problem solving grit this way). I don't know whether that is reasonable, or whether this is a program in which I will need to be more actively teaching / guiding.  The AOPS text looks like it is still written to the student, but it's not quite so "fun," it's denser and there are no pictures  :crying: , and she is only 9. The format of the text is also different from Beast and I'd like to get some ideas on how to approach it and how to pace.  I don't necessarily need her to finish in a certain time frame just for the sake of finishing, but do want to have a rough idea of how to break it up in a reasonable way.

 

Looking at the text, each chapter has sub-sections (e.g. 1.3, 1.4...). Each sub-section has the initial problems, then the explanations / solutions, then a few exercises at the end.  There are 78 total sub-sections, so if we wanted to finish over the course of a year at a relaxed pace, we could try to do one section over 2 days. This would require 156 days, leaving plenty of "room" to slow down if needed (assuming 180 school days/year).  If we did this, I was thinking day 1 would be to read through and attempt the problems. Then read through and understand the first few solutions. Day 2 would be to read through and understand the rest of the solutions, then complete the exercises.  I would check her answers and meet with her each day to talk through the ones she found challenging (that's what I currently do with Beast). 

 

Does that sound reasonable? If you foresee any pitfalls, or if you have other suggestions and advice, I'd love your input! 

 

I see that there are also videos online. Have you found those to be a helpful adjunct? Is the book sufficient (without the videos)?  

 

Ideally, I would work through the text ahead of her, but realistically, I don't know that I'll be able to keep that up consistently.

 

Thank you in advance!


Edited by JHLWTM, 09 November 2017 - 01:08 AM.


#2 Amoret

Amoret

    Hive Mind Larvae

  • Members
  • 36 posts

Posted 09 November 2017 - 06:12 AM

My DS9 is still early in the program, but here is what we do:

 

DS watches relevant videos for the chapter

Works through initial problems/explanations

Completes practice problems

Done for the day

 

He does most of the sections fairly quickly, but the review problems and challenge problems at the end of the chapters are harder and take longer. The videos are helpful to give a context for the initial problems (for example, he had no idea what they were looking for in the very first problem when they said something along the lines of "show that 2+3=3+2". The video introduced the commutative property of addition, which he knew, but didn't realize that was what they wanted.)

 

I am not trying to schedule it out -- I have found AOPS to be uneven and hard to predict -- some days DS flies through it and others, it is a slog (i.e. some sections have taken 30 minutes and others have taken much longer). We have plenty of time, so we are just taking it one day at a time, and when we are done, we will just move on to the next book. I tried to work ahead, but have too many other things to do. We have a math hour where we all sit at the table together and I am available to help as needed. 



#3 regentrude

regentrude

    Qualified Bee Keeper

  • Members
  • PipPipPipPipPipPip
  • 27075 posts

Posted 09 November 2017 - 08:11 AM

We did not use the prealgebra text, because that had not yet been published, but used the rest of the AoPS sequence.

 

I found it hard to predict how long any given section or problem would take, since they vary in difficulty. Without actually working through each problem beforehand it would have been impossible to predict, and even then, without a lot of experience it is very hard to anticipate where the student will have difficulties and get stuck. You don't always see from skimming a problem that it will take an hour to solve.

 

We solved this by not "scheduling" AoPS. We simply set a time for math, kids worked on math, got how far they got, and resumed the next day where they had left off.


  • Julie Smith, dmmetler, slackermom and 1 other like this

#4 SparklyUnicorn

SparklyUnicorn

    Beekeeping Professor

  • Members
  • PipPipPipPipPipPip
  • 38736 posts

Posted 09 November 2017 - 08:37 AM

You might find that it doesn't work so great for a 9 year old.  I would not commit to a rigid schedule either way because the difficulty varies quite a bit.

 

It's just SO SO radically different than BA...that hmmm...it might not be a great fit at this point. 



#5 slackermom

slackermom

    Hive Mind Level 2 Worker: Nurse Bee

  • Members
  • PipPip
  • 1457 posts

Posted 09 November 2017 - 08:51 AM

My kid also started AOPS Pre-Algebra at 9, I believe after finishing BA 4B, since the other books were not out yet. I found we could not keep to my pre-determined schedule of 2 days per sub-section, and just had to develop a routine for the book. AOPS was usually done Monday through Thursday, and we did different math on Friday. The kid consistently chose it as the first subject of the day. At our pace, we did 5 chapters per semester, and finished in 3 semesters. The kid liked to do the following, fairly independently, which usually took 2-3 days, with each day ranging from 45-60 minutes, with a brief check in with me at the end of each math session:

 

-do the initial problems

-read through the solutions/explanations 

-watch the corresponding Richard videos online, usually with me (he is fairly animated, which helped keep the energy up)

-do the exercises

-review the solutions to the exercises

-review the sub-section with me

-do some challenge problems, which we sort of took turns choosing

 

If we had not done other stuff on Fridays, I think we could have gotten through the book in 2 semesters, but I think the pace was good for us. In addition to learning Pre-Algebra, my kid had to learn about ways to tackle more difficult subjects, and we had to address a struggle with perfectionism.

 

 

 

 

 

 


  • rushhush08 and JHLWTM like this

#6 RoundAbout

RoundAbout

    Hive Mind Level 6 Worker: Scout Bee

  • Members
  • PipPip
  • 953 posts

Posted 09 November 2017 - 09:37 AM

My son did AoPS pre-algebra while he was 9 in a little over 9 months working every problem, including challenge problems. We often do a lot of math though and sometimes even on the weekends. 

 

I would throw out the idea of scheduling it at all. Some of the chapters are a breeze, others are very very tough or just time consuming like the rates and proportions chapter. I also did not expect self-teaching. I think its written for an older audience so self-teaching from that text can be a slog for a younger students. Also, I went to a gifted program that entirely expected self-teaching in math and I know that I often took short cuts without thoroughly understanding so did not want to repeat that experience with DS. We do a mix of a math discussion, joint problem solving, and independent work with AoPS and its been very successful so far. 



#7 Arcadia

Arcadia

    Slacker

  • Members
  • PipPipPipPipPipPip
  • 17337 posts

Posted 09 November 2017 - 10:11 AM

My kids self studied for prealgebra and I just grade their work as DS12 has a photographic memory so if he sees the solution in the solution manual, it spoils the fun of correcting his careless mistakes. They have an alcumus account for years and they can post any problems they are stuck on there or even post that they don’t understand the alternative solution in the solution manual.

My kids did the online classes for social reasons and it help keep my easily distracted DS11 on task. He works better with schedules and hard deadlines for any task. He procrastinates on soft deadlines. DS11 started with the original intro to algebra class and the intro to geometry class concurrently after starting the books a year earlier. DS12 started with intermediate algebra class and intro to geometry class concurrently, also after a year of using the books concurrently. My kids like geometry more than algebra so doing the intro to geometry concurrently relieved some boredom of doing the algebra.

My kids started the AoPS books at 8. When BA came out, I bought a set to look see and none of my kids take to it. They rather have the wordy AoPS books.

DS12 has done the books from prealgebra to calculus, including the number theory and the counting and probability books. He thrive on the online class schedule but he is a kid who loves schedules since he was a toddler. DS11 did not thrive as much on the online class schedule but he does worse with no schedules.

My kids found the videos entertaining but they learn better by reading and doing. For video learning, DS11 has to watch more than once as the first time would be spent being distracted by presentation rather than content. My kids counted how many times the presenter wore a particular sweatshirt for example.

My kids has plenty of time for math and other subjects as their friends play soccer and other team sports and my kids aren’t into sports so my kids end up with lots of down time per day. Both kids spend more than an hour a day on math. My DS12 can spend the whole weekend on math if he runs out of books to read. Put my DS12 in a bookstore and he spends the whole day reading.
  • rushhush08 and JHLWTM like this

#8 SanDiegoMom in VA

SanDiegoMom in VA

    Hive Mind Royal Larvae

  • Members
  • PipPip
  • 596 posts

Posted 09 November 2017 - 11:35 AM

My son started at 9 and took about 10 months or so. A calendar year with a break for summer. Scheduling didn't happen -- some days he got one problem done!  Typically he did the initial problems and then watched videos, then the next day did the exercises, but the end of chapter review ALWAYS took long -- like a week long. 

 

 



#9 silver

silver

    Hive Mind Level 2 Worker: Nurse Bee

  • Members
  • PipPip
  • 1121 posts

Posted 09 November 2017 - 02:54 PM

We're in chapter four right now, so this is just what's worked for us so far.

 

He has a certain amount of time that he works on math each day. For some sections, that means it takes two days to do (one day doing the intro w/explanations and one day doing the exercises). For some sections, he's been able to do both the intro and the exercises in one day. The review and challenge sections at the end of each chapter have taken him several days each. We don't use the online videos, but he does Alcumus a few times a week. If he wraps up a section but still has ~10 minutes left, I'll let him do Alcumus with the remaining time.



#10 seaben

seaben

    Hive Mind Larvae

  • Members
  • 24 posts

Posted 09 November 2017 - 02:59 PM

Just to throw another routine out there:  We started AoPS pre-alg in the middle of 2nd grade which was a big lift. Initially we did  10-15  minutes a day with me acting as a tutor and watching how it went. The initial adjustment for the first 4 chapters was fairly hard. Half way through the book or so we switched from reading the exercises to watching the videos instead but otherwise we also worked through all the problems however long it took. Sometimes that looked like 3 weeks on a chapter and I also took the freedom to use the time for additional topic/videos if they looked interesting for example watching a numberphile video (I think this was important from a joy perspective).  Overall adjusting for Summer break this was a 20 mo. process i.e. slow but steady.  I was fairly happy, with the results in terms of retention and growth in problem solving.

 

 

 

 

 

 



#11 JHLWTM

JHLWTM

    Just Visiting

  • Members
  • Pip
  • 280 posts

Posted 09 November 2017 - 06:12 PM

What a wealth of information you all are. Thanks for the input. Could someone explain Alcumus and how you use it? Is it meant to be supplementary? From Arcadia's post, it sounds like there is a "forum" aspect of it where your child can post questions?



#12 JHLWTM

JHLWTM

    Just Visiting

  • Members
  • Pip
  • 280 posts

Posted 09 November 2017 - 06:29 PM

My kid also started AOPS Pre-Algebra at 9, I believe after finishing BA 4B, since the other books were not out yet. I found we could not keep to my pre-determined schedule of 2 days per sub-section, and just had to develop a routine for the book. AOPS was usually done Monday through Thursday, and we did different math on Friday. The kid consistently chose it as the first subject of the day. At our pace, we did 5 chapters per semester, and finished in 3 semesters. The kid liked to do the following, fairly independently, which usually took 2-3 days, with each day ranging from 45-60 minutes, with a brief check in with me at the end of each math session:

 

-do the initial problems

-read through the solutions/explanations 

-watch the corresponding Richard videos online, usually with me (he is fairly animated, which helped keep the energy up)

-do the exercises

-review the solutions to the exercises

-review the sub-section with me

-do some challenge problems, which we sort of took turns choosing

 

If we had not done other stuff on Fridays, I think we could have gotten through the book in 2 semesters, but I think the pace was good for us. In addition to learning Pre-Algebra, my kid had to learn about ways to tackle more difficult subjects, and we had to address a struggle with perfectionism.

 Thanks, slackermom.... umm, from your post, your handle seems to be a misnomer :)

 

I have a strong feeling my DD will want to work as independently as possible. I am thinking I'll need to set aside a 2-4 week transition period for myself. I will lighten up on her other subjects, and also on what I need to do with DS (he cannot work independently yet). During that time, I think I'll let her try on her own, but hover and observe and help her trouble shoot.


  • daijobu likes this

#13 Arcadia

Arcadia

    Slacker

  • Members
  • PipPipPipPipPipPip
  • 17337 posts

Posted 09 November 2017 - 06:48 PM

Could someone explain Alcumus and how you use it? Is it meant to be supplementary? From Arcadia's post, it sounds like there is a "forum" aspect of it where your child can post questions?

Alcumus is supplementary.
“Alcumus offers students a customized learning experience, adjusting to student performance to deliver appropriate problems and lessons”
https://artofproblem...ing.com/alcumus

AoPS forums which uses the same account as Alcumus
https://artofproblem...g.com/community

ETA:
For under 13, there is a consent form to email back to
AoPS to get the account created.

Edited by Arcadia, 09 November 2017 - 06:55 PM.

  • JHLWTM likes this

#14 boscopup

boscopup

    Qualified Bee Keeper

  • Members
  • PipPipPipPipPipPip
  • 11808 posts

Posted 09 November 2017 - 10:30 PM

I've used this book twice now. The first one was with a 9 year old. We spent 2 years on the book, though the second year I was having a complicated pregnancy, so school was kind of hit or miss that year. :p My current 5th grader (just turned 11) is working on it now and is almost done with chapter 2. In both cases, we typically did Problems one day and Exercises the next. Occasionally the Problems will take longer or the Exercises will take longer, and then I split them over a couple days. No big deal. We had to do that with an Exercises section just this week, as it had 11 problems, but the first 5 took a long time. So we did the rest the next day. Review section gets a couple days and Challenge section gets 2-3 days. We do all the problems. With my oldest, I did a lot of handholding the first couple chapters. Once he got to chapter 3, he took off and worked independently. My current student doesn't read well enough to learn from the material on his own, plus he has dysgraphia, so I read the lesson to him, we read the problems together, and we take turns doing the writing. I just ask him what I need to write, and he tells me.

 

Anyway, with you starting so young, feel free to just take your time. It's ok if the book goes past a school year. And don't freak out in the first two chapters... The first chapter is weird - explaining why 2+3=3+2. I understand why they do that, but the student is likely to think, "Well, duh." The second chapter gets into nitty gritty exponents, and if your student hasn't done much with exponents yet, it can move kind of fast. My oldest really struggled with that chapter. My current student is doing better with it, much to my surprise.

 

The videos are great! We usually watch them after doing the problem set.


  • rushhush08 and JHLWTM like this

#15 daijobu

daijobu

    Hive Mind Worker Bee

  • Members
  • PipPipPip
  • 2555 posts

Posted 10 November 2017 - 11:19 PM

 

I have a strong feeling my DD will want to work as independently as possible. I am thinking I'll need to set aside a 2-4 week transition period for myself. I will lighten up on her other subjects, and also on what I need to do with DS (he cannot work independently yet). During that time, I think I'll let her try on her own, but hover and observe and help her trouble shoot.

 

Take a look at message #30 in this thread where I copied verbatim from AoPS prealgebra.  For my own kids (who don't insist on independence) I would write things out as I read them, particularly to illustrate dense paragraphs such as that one.  Reading math is hard, kind of like reading in a foreign language you are still mastering.  


  • JHLWTM and SparklyUnicorn like this

#16 JHLWTM

JHLWTM

    Just Visiting

  • Members
  • Pip
  • 280 posts

Posted 11 November 2017 - 12:34 AM

Take a look at message #30 in this thread where I copied verbatim from AoPS prealgebra.  For my own kids (who don't insist on independence) I would write things out as I read them, particularly to illustrate dense paragraphs such as that one.  Reading math is hard, kind of like reading in a foreign language you are still mastering.  

 

Very helpful. Thanks for the specific example. I think I really will need a transition period to figure out how we'll use this... Will report back in a month or two :)



#17 gold11

gold11

    Hive Mind Larvae

  • Members
  • 2 posts

Posted 11 November 2017 - 11:51 AM

Thanks for asking this question. We are also on the same boat with my 9 year old just starting AoPS Pre-algebra. I am thinking of extending each section into 4 days. First two days to do the problems and exercises and then practice similar problems (that I will get from other sources) for two days to reinforce what he learnt. 


  • JHLWTM likes this

#18 StephanieZ

StephanieZ

    Child Wrangler

  • Members
  • PipPipPipPipPip
  • 7569 posts

Posted 25 November 2017 - 10:29 AM

(Based on 3 kids who've done AoPS for at least several texts), I suggest:

 

+ One section per day (excluding any introductory, #.1 sections and any other similar sections that don't have any problems -- those ones can just be done in a few minutes, then proceed to the next section).

+ 5 days for each end of chapter section (approx 2 days for review and 3 days per challenge section).

 

Depending on the book, this pace generally finishes each book in about 1 to 1.5 school years (about 0.5 year for the C&P and NT texts for my kid, but maybe closer to 1 year if your child is very young and/or working less than 5 hours per week on math) -- depending on the age, skill set, and aptitude of the child and how quickly they work. PreA might be closer to 2 years if your child is young and you're not reliably getting 180 hours of math in during the school year and/or you take time out to work other math curricula.

 

Also, don't forget that if desired, you can mix in using AoPS's Alcumus and/or the videos if your child would benefit from more review (Alcumus -- generally done after working a section or chapter and/or throughout the year, paced anytime after the content is covered in the text) or more teaching/examples (the videos, best used before reading/working each section). 

 

If it's too slow a pace, you can condense your schedule. (I aim for an average of an hour or so of math each school day for under high school *age* and then maybe 1.5 hr/day for high school *age*.)

 

If it's just right pacing, then you can also add supplementary texts (and/or Alcumus time to review past materials) to your schedule as desired if you don't want to start a new text mid-year or if you want to slow them down a bit and/or solidify review material. (At the PreA to Intro to Algebra level, I'd add Patty Paper Geometry -- about 3-4 months if done daily for an hour -- or done 1-2x/wk for an hour over a full year mixed in with something else.)

 

When my dd did PreA very young (about ages 9-10), we took 2 full years to work through the PreA book, after she'd already zoomed through it once doing the online classes over most of the prior year or so) and mixed in PPG at some point (anytime after beginning PreA and before beginning Intro to Geo). No need to rush or to do math for hours per day. Just take your time and work it thoroughly. 

 

This approach has worked well for my dd15, whose done AoPS since PreA (and is now finishing up the last introductory text -- Number Theory) as well as for my older two kids who each started AoPS a bit later in their math careers. (All are very math-y.)

 

Hope this is helpful. 

 

 

 

 


Edited by StephanieZ, 25 November 2017 - 10:30 AM.

  • JHLWTM likes this

#19 regentrude

regentrude

    Qualified Bee Keeper

  • Members
  • PipPipPipPipPipPip
  • 27075 posts

Posted 25 November 2017 - 04:35 PM

update: Offending post has been removed by moderators.

Reported. Violates board rules against advertising.


Edited by regentrude, 26 November 2017 - 09:02 AM.


#20 4kookiekids

4kookiekids

    Hive Mind Queen Bee

  • Members
  • PipPip
  • 937 posts

Posted 25 November 2017 - 09:26 PM

Reported. Violates board rules against advertising.

 

What? Has a post already been deleted, or am I missing how this thread is anybody advertising?



#21 xahm

xahm

    Hive Mind Queen Bee

  • Members
  • PipPip
  • 922 posts

Posted 26 November 2017 - 07:27 AM

What? Has a post already been deleted, or am I missing how this thread is anybody advertising?

Yeah, some tutoring service posted an ad here and elsewhere that has now been removed.
  • regentrude and 4kookiekids like this

#22 JHLWTM

JHLWTM

    Just Visiting

  • Members
  • Pip
  • 280 posts

Posted 26 November 2017 - 05:07 PM

We started last week. So far, it's review, so we're doing about 1 subsection per day and it doesn't feel onerous. After the first 3 days she wanted to try on her own, so I let her. We keep forgetting to watch the videos (I've never done well with curriculum that has many different components  :001_unsure: ). So far so good...


  • StephanieZ likes this

#23 JHLWTM

JHLWTM

    Just Visiting

  • Members
  • Pip
  • 280 posts

Posted 30 January 2018 - 12:41 AM

Updating on what is working for us so far. 

 

DD prefers to work through the book on her own (so far...she is at the end of Chapter 2,...we'll see how things evolve). On average, she works through the problems one day, then the exercises on day 2. If there are a lot of problems or exercises, she'll stretch that section over 3 days. Surprisingly, this model is working well for her, and though she misses the "fun" of Beast, she often says that something from AOPS was the highlight of her day. We never get around to watching the videos. Since she doesn't seem to be struggling, and didn't particularly love the videos, we pretty much gave up on those for now.

 

In case this is helpful for anyone else, I think that one thing that has helped my DD with this transition is embracing the concept of a proof.  Looking back, I recall that sometime last year we had started talking about proofs. I had taken her through a few proofs back in Beast 5, showing her how to write out each step so she could follow her own logic to prove to herself that math concept x was true and generalizable to other number examples. I starting making her write out the steps to her logic for 1 problem a day sometime when she was doing Beast 5.  She saw it as busy work then, but now I think it's really given her the skills to slow down and codify her thinking in an organized way. Instead of needing to get used to the "style" of AOPS, she can engage with the content more directly.  I think the modeling of the "proof" has been really helpful in this transition for her, since AOPS is all about proofs.

 

 


  • kiana, slackermom and 4kookiekids like this