perhaps not "terribly" disrespectful but it did come across as dismissive. It seemed like she was not going to listen to constructive criticism. I wonder if all her wins in the beginning, after Tim G. was giving her criticism about her aesthetic, actually hindered her in the end. I mean if someone says..."think about your color choices and design." (or however they say it), but you go with it anyway and then the judges reward you, you're going to stop listening to the nay sayers.