I don't like my appliances out, mainly because they get dirty and collect animal hair. I *hate* pulling my bagel out of the toaster and finding cat hair on it. Gag.
So I had my dh build a wooden appliance cover. It looks similar to this:
but the front is plain with one metal handle that matches the cupboard handles. It's painted off white to match the kitchen cabinets. The back is open, so it just slides forward when I want to use the toaster.
My old house had a built in appliance cover on the counter, similar to this:
It wouldn't work in my current kitchen, but I want this in my next house.