But, Ester, of course it is different. They are two different fields of medicine. Psychiatry is not internal medicine . . . one cannot get inside the human mind, cannot accumulate OBJECTIVE data, in diagnosing mental illness. Diagnosis is made in large part by patient's reported symtpoms. I agree it's not an exact science, but it's a starting point. Because there is no objective way to diagnose via labs or what not does mean the illness is not there.
Of course, as with anything, benefit should outweigh risk for the patient. And I fully realize that the ideal of having a mental health professional perform a thorough assessment before diagnosing depression and suggesting psychotropics is not realized for some. For some, it is the front line of the family doctor who prescribes them. I agree one should research before making the decision to see if, in fact, the risk is worth the benefit. For many who have shared their stories here, it clearly is.
Lisa