I run into the same thing here with ds10. I've been looking at "classics", both modern and older, a bit below his reading level and just picking a few to require him to read. If there's dated language and I really want him to hear it, I read it aloud to everyone. If it still bombs, I shelve it until later. The Secret Garden was like that. Everyone tolerated it, but it's pretty slow so we've shelved it for a bit. This year he's read The Door in the Wall, The Great Brain, Best Christmas Pageant Ever, Farmer Boy, Cricket in Times Square, Dangerous Journey and Castle Diary. Adam of the Road bombed. I'm going to have him finish the year with Crispin: The Cross of Lead by Avi. I'm just trying to expand the genres he's exposed to at this point, as he reads dozens of nonfiction and Star wars, mine craft, my weird school series type books on his own. Next year we're trying for The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe, A Wrinkle in Time, Holes, My Side of The Mountain, Hoot, Sherlock Files Book 1 and Johnny Tremain. We'll see what happens. ;-)