My older boys were bored out of their minds with Phonics Pathways and OPGTR. I could not be more serious. Truly, they were utterly bored.
I've heard great things about the Abeka phonics program.
We now use Explode the Code and Happy Phonics games, and the Happy Phonics IG explains how to use the two together. My younger boys love this combo. Writing when learning to read helps reinforce the phonics, it adds some activity, and as a bonus gives the kids a head start on spelling. Because writing is involved (with ETC not HP), we do short lessons in the beginning.