I wear size 10.5WW (or, huge boats) and *love* my red shoes. They're Hush Puppies floral skimmers, slide on leather shoes that seem to go with just about everything, are comfortable, and cute! Hard to find cute at this size!
My wardrobe is largely navy and gray with bits of red, teal, and blue. I'll happily wear the red shoes with almost every outfit in my wardrobe.