I didn't say it was the determining factor. I said (or implied) all other things being EQUAL, I'd go with the virgin. I know I'm not alone on that one. Flame away!
My "Ew, Sorry Just Ew" moment(s) would (theoretically) be when I picture myself with Mr. Experienced and wonder how I measure up compared to Sally, or Jane or Mollly or Nancy or, or , or . . . .
Twenty two years ago I married a virgin just a few months shy of 37 y.o. He is a wonderful husband and my best friend. So I find your comment about older virgins "creeping" you out distasteful. But it is your opinion, so no offense taken. Good night!