I thought I had decided on Winter Promise American Story 1 for next school year but after reading so many negative reviews on here I'm second-guessing my decision. Has anyone used AS 1 and actually enjoyed it? I didn't plan on ordering anything but the WP exclusive items directly from WP because of all the shipping issues people have had. I like the idea of WP because of the hands-on activities. I think my son would really enjoy this aspect. History pockets were a big bust here and I don't know how much he would get out of the 3D maps but I was planning on ordering the Early American Trades & Crafts Kit to balance it out. Is this kit really worth the money? It makes me a little uneasy that the website doesn't list anything that's included in the kit.
So, since I'm starting to have doubts about WP I've been looking at Sonlight's Core 3 package again. It bothers me that's there are no hands on projects with their curriculum but I love their book choices. It also looks like geography is covered which is something WP lacks. Are SL's geography lessons pretty complete? It would be great if we didn't have to order an additional geography program since we would be spending so much on the Core.
So, I guess my main question is, what would you choose? I really want to use something that comes with most everything we need for the year so I'm hoping to make one of these programs work. We haven't had great luck relying on the library and I'm just plain tired of having to scrounge everything up myself.
Thanks so much for any help! I appreciate it. :)