Menu
Jump to content
ATTENTION: Forums search will not work until re-indexing is completed. Please follow these instructions for search

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

faiths13

ILL vs. English for the Thoughtful Child? Simply Grammar?

Recommended Posts

I have been using Intermediate Language Lessons by Emma Serl from Google Books for free. I was looking around for a copy to buy to make it easier and came across English For The Thoughtful Child. It also looks great. I also have a copy of Simply Grammar from the library. I really like the ILL and I like adding in SG for more grammar. But Im wondering if EFTTC would be better then ILL? Has anyone used both? Do you think using one of those and SG too is too much of the same thing? Thanks!!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

They are not comparable. EFTTC is for first and second grade. Serl's ILL is for fourth and fifth grades. ILL would be more suitable for your students' ages.

 

I think that SG and ILL would be "too much of the same thing". I didn't like SG much when I looked at samples online. ILL is more interesting.

 

This hardcover edition of ILL is the cheapest, I think.

 

Hope that helps you make a decision.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
They are not comparable. EFTTC is for first and second grade. Serl's ILL is for fourth and fifth grades. ILL would be more suitable for your students' ages.

 

I think that SG and ILL would be "too much of the same thing". I didn't like SG much when I looked at samples online. ILL is more interesting.

 

This hardcover edition of ILL is the cheapest, I think.

 

Hope that helps you make a decision.

 

In addition, I remember reading reviews in several places that Simply Grammar was not as good. We love PLL and I just received ILL and Teacher's Guide in the mail yesterday. This will be our main grammar program for next year, in conjunction with a Galore Park Junior English Book 2/3, alternating days. I added GP as a supplement because ds asked me for more creative assignments. Instead of comprehension questions I have him narrate. It also gets him used to reading modern pieces, including informational ones.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
They are not comparable. EFTTC is for first and second grade. Serl's ILL is for fourth and fifth grades. ILL would be more suitable for your students' ages.

 

I think that SG and ILL would be "too much of the same thing". I didn't like SG much when I looked at samples online. ILL is more interesting.

 

This hardcover edition of ILL is the cheapest, I think.

 

Hope that helps you make a decision.

 

Helpful post. I picked up EFTTC at a used curricuclum sale last year and I was wondering if it was any good.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

so far I like SG - I would use it in addition to either ILL or EFTTC. I am going to try to pick up all 3, if I can find them used. I am just to tempted to not check out EFTTC. The writing looks great in it.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

We have just started with the CM style, so I think the writing in the book would be great. I am pretty excited by the samples. The grammar may be too light, but we can skip through those pages.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

My children and I thoroughly enjoyed Simply Grammar. It does, as the name implies, just cover Grammar. My children actually asked to do lessons. That's a winner by me. They enjoyed making their own sentences, which we did completely orally. I participated by making sentences as well.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I've been very happy with both PLL and ILL. ILL is for 4-6th gr. range. I haven't used Simply Grammar so I can't compare.I find Serl's materials to be thorough and covers a lot of ground.

 

How about using reading Grammar-Land aloud and have them use the worksheets--http://www.hslaunch.com/mypage/profile/525

 

I have a two 11 yr. olds and they are in ILL and we do Grammar-Land 1x a week. They've learned alot from GL. Come ages 13, I will have them do Our Mother Tongue alongside Write with the Best.

 

Also, the Teacher's Guide for ILL is a must, IMO. I got the ILL hardback and its TG from Amazon.

 

HTH,

Rachel

 

**amendment: I just went and looked at the samples and age range (up to 8th) for SG and I actually think it would complement ILL since it's focus is strictly on Grammar, whereas ILL is LA in general. I still recommend GL and the worksheets, but I don't know how old your oldest is (I guess I shouldv'e looked) and how they'd respond to the story-like concept within GL. Both of mine get a kick out it.

Anyway, I'm considering picking up myself as an in-between after GL and before OMT.

Hope you find what's best for ya'll.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

SUBSCRIBE TO OUR NEWSLETTER & RECEIVE A COUPON FOR
10% OFF
We respect your privacy.You’ll hear about new products, special discounts & sales, and homeschooling tips. *Coupon only valid for first-time registrants. Coupon cannot be combined with any other offer. Entering your email address makes you eligible to receive future promotional emails.
0 Shares
Share
Tweet
Pin
×