I did GWG in 1st & 2nd grade with my oldest, then switched to R&S for 3rd. Now I'm thinking of going back! Ack! I just want to set a course, KWIM? :) R&S has too much writing so we've been doing it almost all orally. I was thinking GWG might be a nice combo, we'd go over the lesson together then he could do the worksheet independently.
The parts I like about R&S - it has all the grades, it has review questions each day, and tests at the end of a unit.
The part I don't like is only that ds has to hand write all the answers so we end up doing it all orally (he despises writing, but doesn't mind workbooks. I think they trick him into writing.). I wonder about him not doing written practice. Will it stick?
I switched from GWG b/c ds was doing it all on his own and I thought I should know what's going on in his lessons a bit more (teach the teacher). Anyway, what do you think?