What worked for us:
DD (7):
Spelling you see B, her spelling is outstanding right now and I feel I owe it all to SYS.
Math combination of Horizon and Singapore. She wasn't grasping story problems and Singapore came to the rescue. When she bounced back into Horizon book 2 she was much better prepared.
Abeka language 1, has just been so outstanding. It is thorough and she loves it.
First Language Lessons 1, has been a hit with her. She enjoys the time with me when we do it and her speech has also benefited.
DS X2 (the 6 year old twins)
Abeka language 1. I bumped them both into it half way through the year and it was the best decision. One is reading Magic Tree house now and the other is comfortably reading leveled readers.
Math u see alpha and Rightstart math B. I put each twin in a different math based on learning styles. At first it was more work for me but now it is like nothing and I can easily do both. Either math would not work for the other if I reversed them. It is amazing how math is that subject where you really do need to find the right fit. This works and we are sticking with it.
Subjects with all 3 that worked:
SOTW 1 with Biblioplan Ancient. This was perfect. So so fun and every single one has eaten it up. I am going to be sad to finish it up.
Mommy's homemade Africa continent study. We used Draw Africa as a spine, 10 days in Africa game, and Africa geopuzzle to focus on each country. Each week we would draw,trace or label 2 countries and I would get books about each country to read that week. They could be about people, myths, customs, animals, basically whatever we could find. It has been phenomenally successful. All 3 kids can rattle off each country using a blank map and tell things about each one. Eritrea was a favorite and they loved learning about the Mangrove Trees.
RS4K Geology paired with Geology Rocks! This was a great science study and we all learned a ton. We did chocolate chip cookie archeology digs, made a homemade seismigraph, grew crystals in egg shells, made sedementary rocks and so much more. It was truly an outstanding time.
What didn't work for us:
Reason for Handwriting: my kiddos hated it. I thought it was cute but it brought the twins to tears and made my daughter's handwriting worse. We switched to Draw Write Now! and that was much better.
All About Spelling:this was too confusing for the kids used alongside Abeka. I may revisit this at later levels as I really like it but it just didn't work for us.
Abeka 1 writing. When my DD and I both started rolling our eyes during each lesson I knew it was time to abandon ship. Same goes for Abeka 1 spelling. Just didn't work. Nothing was being retained so we abandoned it.