NM

[Sweet Home Alabama]

Thanks, ladies!

Edited February 25, 2017 by Sweet Home Alabama

[Momto6inIN]

Not inexpensive AT ALL, but Analytical Grammar meets all your other requirements. I think doing season 1 for 9 weeks or so would be ideal for 5th/6th graders, then move on to your modified WWE stuff for the remainder of the year using what you learned in grammar the first 9 weeks.

 

Hopefully someone else chimes in for you! :)

[Sweet Home Alabama]

I wish I could use AG. I used it with my kids. It's just too expensive.

Thanks so much for suggesting it though!

[OneStepAtATime]

Fix-It Grammar?

 

http://iew.com/fix

[RootAnn]

Did you delete because you found something or because time ran out?

 

I wish I could have helped. The only thing I could weigh in on was the Memoria Press Grammar Recitations, but I've never seen the workbooks at any level. We have the actual Grammar Recitation book & I've used it to come up with questions & answers for the kids to memorize. I've found that I had to pick & choose across many of the 'levels' to get what I wanted.

 

FLL4 is a good book, but I thought it was either too expensive or too teacher-led to work for a co-op situation. The new ALL (whatever it is named now) might have been a good pick as you could have the core book & they could have the workbook level 1, but I don't know what it will end up costing and whether you needed it already this semester.

 

I also thought of Growing With Grammar, but perhaps that was too expensive or not good enough for what you were hoping to do?

Anyway, I hope you found something.

[Sweet Home Alabama]

Hi RootAnn,

Thank you so much for replying. 

I am leaning toward using the MP Recitation book.

I was so relieved to find this resource.  I think it will be just the thing I was hoping to find.

I've used FLL before, but I don't remember Growing with Grammar.  I'll try to look at that one.