I have the full set of the original (reprinted) 1836 McGuffey's Primers and Readers and am reading through Ruth Beechick's Parent-Teacher Guide for them.
I am wondering if anyone has used them. And if so, did they ever seem too archaic? They seem pretty sound, drill intensive, and integrative.
My ds6 is rising into first year of homeschool as a first grader from a Christian kindergarten school and I can see gaps in his understanding that, though seemingly patched over by his natural brightness and inquisitive nature, will most likely show up later. He has a tremendous vocabulary and is a great reader already, however, it seems to me that at times he guesses at pronunciation based on context rather than a sound foundation in phonics.
I'm not really that concerned as I plan on emphasizing the basics with ds4, and naturally ds6 will be exposed to it once more, and hopefully in a more complete sequence than what he got last year.