TOG users what is the Alt Textbook for Y3?

[M&M]

We are finishing up Y2 and dd likes the Western Civ textbook better than the primary resources this year. It looks like she would prefer to use a textbook next year. Dd thinks she would like to use BJU, just read a chapter and take a test.

 

Since I would still like to do TOG or at least history ala WTM, I was wondering what text TOG uses for Y3.

 

Thanks for your help.

[delaney]

:bigear:

[M&M]

Really....no one can tell me?

[Brigid in NC]

My Year 3 is the 2003 version, not the newest edition. So the alternates may have changed. In mine, there are four listed:

 

Dialectic/Rhetoric:

 

 

• BJU - World History for Christian Schools, Second Edition (1993)
  
• BJU - United States History for Christian Schools, Second Edition (1994)
  

 

Rhetoric:

 

 

• Spielvogel - Western Civilization, Fourth Edition, Comprehensive Volume (2000)
  
• Christian Liberty Press - Streams of Civilization, Volume 2, Second Printing (1995)
  

 

:001_smile:

[Shelly in VA]

From the Lampstand Bookshelf site, the list of rhetoric alternate history resources is here:

 

https://www.lampstandbookshelf.com/ZC/index.php?main_page=resources&step=2&year=3&units=all&LR=on&subjects=some&S1=on&type=alternate

 

There isn't a textbook-type spine listed for Y3. There is a strong emphasis that year on American History and the presidents, so the only book listed for multiple weeks in the rhetoric level is The American Presidency by Brinkley and Dyer; in the dialectic level, both Our Island Story and This Country of Ours by H.E. Marshall are listed. I thought I used a textbook alternate resource last year with my then 7th and 9th grade kids, but I guess I did not.

 

HTH.

 

Shelly