Is yours also confused as to why everyone is "against her"? It's the complete lack of self awareness that gets me. Neither of her sons are talking to her at the moment. BIL stopped after MIL sent his eldest daughter, E, (then 20) back every card, letter, etc. she'd ever sent her Grandma on E's birthday, because she was insufficiently grateful for Grandma's advice. E's entire interaction with MIL for a decade had been hearing about how she should do this, this, and this or she was going to be a failure in life, and, "See, I told you so." I'm in awe she lasted that long. But, neither DH nor BIL learned to set boundaries other than cutting her off, so this has been an ongoing pattern in their adult relationship with her and they haven't been able to model healthy boundary setting for the kids with respect to her.