Jump to content

Menu

astrid

Members
  • Posts

    4,771
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by astrid

  1. Absolutely arm our teachers and principals. I think we are crazy not to. Our children deserve to be able to go to safe schools without fear and if that's what it takes...so be it.

     

     

    I don't agree.

     

    1. We have had numerous threads here over the years about how we (collective "we") have chosen to homeschool because, among other reasons, we feel that there are many kids in public school who are impacted by a variety of issues: behavioral, mental health, etc. What's to stop one from overpowering the teacher and getting control of the gun?

     

    2. Where would this gun be kept? Would teachers wear a holster? What about body armor? If you're asking a teacher to arm themselves, shouldn't they at least have the protection that an armed police officer wears when carrying a weapon?

     

    3. What if, in the course of a hypothetical firefight with a hypothetical intruder, children are caught in the crossfire? Generally the teacher does not stand right inside the classroom door at all times. Generally the students, desks, tables, bookcases, etc. are between the teacher and the door to the classroom.

     

    4. Teachers are now expected to be an educator, parent, morality coach, social worker and nurse to the children in their classrooms. Adding "armed guard," and charging them with the task of using firepower to keep the children safe is certainly a tall order.

     

    5. Who bears the liability if the gun is taken by a student, the gun discharges erroneous, or a student is caught in the crossfire while a teacher is shooting at an intruder? The teacher who pulled the trigger? The school district that armed the teacher and directed her to use it?

     

    6. IF this is implemented, with whom do we fill the classrooms vacated by teachers who would rather quit their job than carry a loaded weapon? Surely there would be a mass exodus of educators leaving the profession. So who covers the shortages?

     

    7. Who pays for the guns, ammunition, training, upkeep and liability policies? Much of the nation is completely overburdened with the cost of education now. Should we eliminate band and choir to pay for handguns and bullets? What kind of a sad statement on education is that?

     

    8. What if some parents (like me) balk at the idea of their child sharing space with a gun, a whole bunch of video-game-obsessed teenagers and a quickly trained, nervous teacher? Could parents opt out? Or would parents be forced to send their student into an environment where the atmosphere is so anxious that the teacher has to wear a gun?

     

    Those are just a few points dashed off as I race to a meeting----- I'm interested to hear some possible solutions or answers to the questions I've posed.

     

    astrid

  2. I know that, Jean. Many of us did experience the public school system though, and I actually have a lot of respect for the teachers there who are just as fed up with the system as those of us who find ourselves leaving it. I don't think one is more or less virtuous for when they decided to homeschool.

     

     

     

    Astrid, you are right. Thanks for clarifying for me.

     

    I have a just retired teacher who approached me and asked if she could work with our kids a couple mornings a week in language arts. She was a FABULOUS teacher, and was completely and utterly fed up with the system, which is the only reasno she quit. She was tired of seeing kids lose their joy, tired of being unable to really teach rather than test and read from teacher's manuals. She's been amazing with our kids, and I was thrilled when she told me one month into it, "Now THIS is teaching! We used to be able to do a lot of this in the classroom...I didn't even realize how much I miss it."

     

    When we decided to pull our kids, all 3 of our sons' teachers privately pulled me aside and told me they thought it was a wise decision on my part, that they supported me 100%, and two even gave me home numbers to call to offer help if I never needed it. Many, many teachers know what is wrong. Sure, some are misguided in their thinking, in my opinion, but there are thousands who "get it" and are as burned out and frustrated as children and their parents are. But if someone wants to earn a living and truly wants to teach...where to do they go? There are only so many private schools out there.

     

    I guess I have a lot of empathy for people like the gentleman in the video.

     

    Cindy

     

     

     

    The bolded above is EXACTLY the reason why I quit teaching public school (7th grade English) in 2001. I even had a letter to the editor published in the NEA monthly magazine regarding this. DD wants to be a special education teacher and I have to bite my tongue to keep from screaming NOOOOO!!!!! But her heart is so big and she really wants to follow that heart. Hoping things will change, but not betting on it. :-(

     

    astrid

  3. Have you all seen this? Makes my heart break a little for all the wonderful teachers our kids had before electing to homeschool...and they WERE wonderful. The system hinders our teachers in such frustrating ways, I am surprised we don't have more quitting.

     

    http://twentytwoword...job-on-youtube/

     

    Cindy

    Not all of us quit public schooling to homeschool. Some of us have chosen it all on it's own.

     

    I'm assuming she was referring to the wonderful teachers HER PERSONAL children had before she pulled them out to begin homeschooling?

    I don't think it was a collective "our." I could be wrong, but I don't think she meant it as any kind of blanket statement.

     

    astrid

  4. Or use the poster as a wrapping? Maybe find something small for a dc that will fit in the tube, inside the rolled poster (which I assume expands and hugs the interior walls of the tube?)

     

    So get something long and slender (a big SlimJim?) and put it in the tube. Attach a cute gift tag on a long ribbon to the inside of the tube (behind poster) and to the end of the Slim Jim. Shove Slim Jim and long ribbon into tube, wrap as normal, and address it to a dc. So dc opens the gift, out falls the slim and the long ribbon attaching it to another gift tag, and telling him to hand off the tube to dh. Who then finds the poster and you all sing and be merry.

     

     

    Just a thought----

     

    astrid

  5. IMO- violent video games/movies, loss of morals/lack of Christian values, medicating children, drug/alcohol use with young adults, dealing with bullies, major economic issues, broken families...

     

    I have no problems with guns... a gun in the wrong hands- that's the problem.

     

     

     

    While I agree with most of your list, I just want to point out that Christians are not the only ones with "values" and "morals."

     

    astrid

  6. Local news reporting teachers were stuffing children into cabinets and under sinks to save them. One class is completely unaccounted for. Oh god they are all just babies!

    I just got a robocall from Molly's school and just about voided my contents. Increased police presence at dismissal, all afterschool activities cancelled, kids being told at 1:45.

  7. I know-- so upsetting! I'm at my office in Hartford, at Capitol Region Education Council where we do lots of professional development training for teachers and administrators. My office is right next to a big room where there's always Friday teacher/admin workshops going on-- and today it's packed. The hallway is just now FILLED with teachers and admins trying to call back to their schools in that region, and they're all poking their heads into my office to ask if I've seen any more info on the local news website. It's awful....

     

    astrid

×
×
  • Create New...