I still don't feel like I've found "the one" as far as history curricula/plans go! This year we are using MFW's CtG, and it's going well. However, I just realized that I don't use much of what's in the teacher's manual -- I've even added my own spine The Story of the Ancient World by Guerber/Miller, which is our favorite part of history!
After a busy year last year (outside of school), I wanted the schedule that MFW would provide. I use MFW's scripture memory, weekly topics (but use the spine above), read alouds (but get ahead of their schedule), and some of their other history readings (Victor, which has gone in order; Ancient World & Ancient Egypt). We didn't like their main science text, so I've replaced it.
The book basket idea of browsing books on the week's topic isn't working as well as I'd like -- the kids would rather read whole books. I think it would work better for me to assign history reading, and I'd like help with grade-appropriate suggestions. I'd like to try something with weekly reading assignments by grade level, or at least a narrowed down list by grade level.
So...next year we'll be ready for 6th & 4th grade and year 2 of the history cycle. I'm wondering about:
~ Biblioplan since it lists reading assignments by grade ranges.
~ TOG, but it seems so expensive. Plus, I don't consider history one of our most important subjects -- important, yes, but I don't feel we have time to "major" in history. (Any thoughts on these TOG concerns?) We are also using and loving CW, so I'm not sure I'd use the TOG writing.
~ Sticking with MFW, and going to RtR, which would schedule SOTW & additional readings (or maybe I'd only need SOTW & the activity guide to accomplish something close?)
~ Or going more on my own by using something like the next Guerber book and the supplemental reading guide in the back (or maybe All Through the Ages for more ideas--haven't seen this in person).
Can you guys help me sort through this a bit? My dc love to read other, non-history-related literature, so I want to make sure to leave reading time for this too. (So, not an overwhelming amount of history reading.) I like that TOG includes literature too. This is another area that I don't yet have a concrete plan. (I love the feeling of having a plan and hate feeling like I'm flying by the seat of my pants.) One of the things we enjoy most about using Story of the Ancient World is the continuous narrative it provides.
Sorry so long!! Any suggestions?