Well to me classical is latin based / literature based/ history based. I do tend to like most of SBW's suggestions. I require my children to do atleast 2 languages besides Latin. Four years of Foreign Language, English, Math, Science, Arts, Music, etc. I do the history and science rotations.
I don't think there is a pat answer to that question. There are just as many variations as there are homeschoolers I suppose.
I think most people would call me the overkill type. But it worked for my olders. Hopefully it will with these too.