Do I need the DVDs for Traditional Logic

[Quiver0f10]

Or can this be done easily without them? Thanks!

[CAMom]

Are you referring to Memoria Press? If so, I do think you need the dvds. We completed the fist book this year and I don't think we could have easily done it without the dvds.

[Cedarmom]

We did it without. We bought the dvd's for logic 1, but did not use them. We found them dry, and for us did not add any more info.

[schmittgirlz]

If you have a background in logic, e.g., Fallacy Detective and Teaching Toolbox, or if the student exhibits higher order thinking skills and is self-motivated then the DVDs are not necessary. With that being said, I did purchase the DVD set for Traditional Logic II to ensure content is mastered.

 

HTH!

 

Clare

[Quiver0f10]

Thanks, I will probably will get them to make sure everything is covered.

[Jan P.]

I've taught TL I twice. I didn't use the dvds for TL1. I did teach TL II once to my ds, but I wished that I had the dvd for this course. If I teach TL II again, then I will get the dvd for it.

 

Gotta go -- a storm is a comin'

 

Jan P.

[Retired]

Traditional Logic 2 DVDs needed

[Kanga]

I did not use them with my dd, but I did with my ds. It is another format for the same information and IMHO if they are needed depends on your child's learning style. My ds is a visual learner, so I felt they were necessary for him. He watched the videos first and then reviewed by reading the book.

[Quiver0f10]

Thanks again for the replies. I appreciate the help!

[summer]

On Latina Christiana 1 (also by Memoria Press) I have found more content in the DVDs than in the teacher's guide. DD would be missing a couple things if we did not have the DVDs. I have been watching along with her. So I am suspecting the same thing could be true with the logic classes. I do not know for sure, I just suspect it.