Jump to content

Menu

if you assume First Language Lessons for 1st...


momma aimee
 Share

Recommended Posts

OK, maybe I'm a freak this way, but I have a terrible time telling pre-k from K from 1st. Maybe it's because we school year round. Maybe it's because Monkey's definitely got some asynchronous development going on. He still can't write all this lowercase letters, is nearly finished with the K math we're doing, and does better quality narrations than the SOTW1AG suggests 1st graders might offer. Sometimes his narrations are just too funny and I have to giggle a bit.

 

I guess I'm saying that I'd worry less about "grade level" and more about is your child ready for the material. If he's not then wait. If he is, then FLL1 is nice because it's easy to do orally & takes all of 5 minutes 2-3 times a week. No kittens will die if he doesn't learn about nouns & pronouns in K. His earning power 30 years from now will likely hardly notice either way. It's just not worth loosing sleep over either way, IYKWIM. :D

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I think most schools don't start grammar until 1st, and even then, it's VERY little (like nouns and action verbs). You don't need grammar in K. You need to focus on learning to read and write letters. Without that foundation, you have no use for grammar. ;)

 

FLL1 is very gentle and perfectly suitable to a K'er, but if the child isn't reading and writing yet, I wouldn't bother. You have plenty of time to do grammar. You could easily wait until 2nd grade or later and be just fine.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Well, I'm going to go in another direction.

 

FLL gave us a great way to work on oral/auditory language development when vision & SPD/fine motor delay issues prevented ds from making headway with reading & writing. I don't see this discussed often, but there is only so much :banghead: you can do with teaching reading and it is fantastic to have a different way to approach language instruction.

 

I think I saw from your siggie that your ds is in some therapies too, so I'm going to suggest you try it for the above reasons. With these kinds of kiddos, the brain development is there but some of the other issues can get in the way, and having an oral method of teaching language keeps them progressing while their bodies learn to compensate with the therapies.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

We switched from unschooling to classical when my oldest would have started kindergarten last fall (he was 5.5), and he started FLL at that time, no problem, but he was way beyond ready for a more formal curriculum and raced through kindergarten in about two months. We skipped the "enrichment" activities at the ends of the lessons.

 

My daughter is just finishing kindergarten now (she's 4.5), and since she was almost a year and a half younger when she started, we focused on letter recognition and sounds (Leapfrog Letter Factory took care of that), number recognition (Leapfrog Numbers Ahoy) and beginning math skills (RightStart Math Level A). She loves workbooks, so I had her fine-tune her motor skills with those in preparation for beginning penmanship. Once she had the letter sounds down we started OPGTR. We only just started FLL with her last week, when she'd acquired most of the first grade skills.

 

So long story short: it depends on the kid and their development. You can always try it and see if it seems to be going well; if not, hang it back up for a while.

Edited by go_go_gadget
Link to comment
Share on other sites

We did FLL 1 in K and had no problem. I read everything to dd since she couldn't read yet. We didn't do the writing parts. She loved it and enjoyed memorizing the poems. The grammar was gentle, but it stuck with her. You could see if your kiddo is ready now. If not, just wait for 1st grade. Don't worry about getting behind. Every kid is different at this early stage.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Well, I'm going to go in another direction.

 

FLL gave us a great way to work on oral/auditory language development when vision & SPD/fine motor delay issues prevented ds from making headway with reading & writing. I don't see this discussed often, but there is only so much :banghead: you can do with teaching reading and it is fantastic to have a different way to approach language instruction.

 

I think I saw from your siggie that your ds is in some therapies too, so I'm going to suggest you try it for the above reasons. With these kinds of kiddos, the brain development is there but some of the other issues can get in the way, and having an oral method of teaching language keeps them progressing while their bodies learn to compensate with the therapies.

 

This is intresting -- I may try it -- I plan it for 1st if not this year, so no harm in getting it. I like it can be done orally -- his handvritting is still a struggle, more for unease trying than a real delay -- he is delayed some, but also fustrated by it.

 

I lik the idea of approaching things from many sides -- covering the same "learning" in more than one style or manner --

 

if not, bokkshelf till 2nd semester or net fall.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Just focus on phonics and reading and learning to write for k. I had kept my boys together for LA for a couple years and so technically DS2 was kindy when I did FLL1 with him and it was hard for him. We did FLL2 when he was in 1st grade (me still wanting to keep the boys together) and now he's repeating 2nd grade grammar with R&S. He just needed the extra time. Especially being a boy, I think. I'm learning not to push boys.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Just focus on phonics and reading and learning to write for k. I had kept my boys together for LA for a couple years and so technically DS2 was kindy when I did FLL1 with him and it was hard for him. We did FLL2 when he was in 1st grade (me still wanting to keep the boys together) and now he's repeating 2nd grade grammar with R&S. He just needed the extra time. Especially being a boy, I think. I'm learning not to push boys.

 

that is my mantra -- 'he is a boy, he is young, do not push'

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

 Share

×
×
  • Create New...