12 weeks into third grade now.
WINNERS
NOEO Chemistry. Love the large collection of books to learn from. An improvment over R.E.A.L. Science, which we also loved but the simple black and white pages and bad illutrations were uninspiring. Plus the "preperation time" vs "stuff learned" ratio wasn't good.
Saxon 3. Seems to be a lot meatier than Saxon 1 or 2, and it's good to see the foundation laid in the prior years paying off. We've been using Saxon since Kindergarten and she's so used to the style of instruction that she learns new things very very quickly. I'm glad we stuck with one program.
Latin for Children. I can't express how much we love this program. The dvds are home-movie quality but we don't much notice or care. The teacher is clear and easy to understand. I get it the first time through and am able to help her through each week's lesson. a good thing as I have no latin experience. My mother, who is learning Latin with a book for adults, just saw what we use and wants it for herself!
FLL 3. I can't believe how effortless we're (both) learning what I believe is really hardcore grammar. Thanks to FLL 1 and 2 for laying the foundation. Couldn't make it through FLL 3 without it, I think.
LOSERS
History Odyssey, early modern. I thought it would be easier to learn history with this program, which lays things out more accordning to geography and doesn't go through chronologically. Big mistake. I find it to be confusing as we jump back and forth between centuries. Chronological learning was so much better. Definitely going back to SOTW order next year. I AM glad, however, than the American Revolution is going to get several, uninterrupted weeks. but that's a subject dear to me so I'm biased.
Writing Strands. We're planning on doing level 2 and 3 this year. It seems fairly useless so far, maybe because my daughter seems to have a natural writing ability and doesn't need to be taught the real basics. I'm hoping it gets more useful later on. I don't really like the anti-grammar stance the introduction takes either.
That's pretty much it. Hope somebody finds this useful.