My son is taking LTOW I this year with Renee Mathis and I am very pleased with the class. I have been watching all the lectures with him, so that I can help him apply what he learns in the class to his other writing. This is the first time ever that I have felt like I could actually be a help to my kids with writing. My daughter isn't even taking the class, and some of the basic ideas that I've picked up in this class have also helped me to guide her.
Ds has had years of IEW classes and while he was strong in grammar, punctuation, sentence structure and variation, writing complete paragraphs, etc. he was still struggling to write papers for his lit class. What I started to realize is that he had no idea how to come up with strong arguments and support them. He didn't know what he wanted to say. LTOW is very simple, but it puts a huge emphasis on the brainstorming process. My son is being forced to put a lot of thought into why he is making his argument and he has to come up with plenty of reasons for and against it. That is turning out to be The Answer for him. He's recently been working on his first lit paper this year and we've been implementing the brainstorming process using the questions from LTOW and it has gone so much more smoothly than it ever has before.
The focus on the structure of the essay has also been helpful to us, but the focus on the brainstorming process is what really makes LTOW different IMO. While it isn't a method that I found easy to automatically apply to other types of writing, I was able to ask for help on the LTOW message board and I'm really starting to get how it's done now.
I will say that when we first began the class, I was a bit disappointed because it didn't seem like there was much to it and it was moving so slowly, but as we continued, it all started to click and I began to see the beauty of it.