This is my first year homeschooling - I have a daughter in 2nd grade. My vision for this year was to nail down basic math skills and to inspire her curiosity.
I have a son still in ps who will be graduating this year. We were very fortunate that he has been in a special AG program since 4th grade that was a perfect fit for him - but his curiosity was his motivation for his success. He has been accepted at all 5 schools to which he applied - he was invited to compete for scholarship at three of them - one has offered him a full academic scholarship so far and he's waiting for decisions on the other two.
I want my daughter to have similar opportunities. Unfortunately, we have not been able to get her into the program that he has been in.
So, we are homeschooling. I really do feel that less is more. It was not just learning all of the "facts" that got my son these opportunities - it was his curiosity, and his love of reading. We stick very closely to our math program and moderately work on other language basics. We also enjoy a moderate schedule with SOTW spending much time reading from the recommended literature lists. Then, I like to keep most of our schedule free to go to various field trips or to travel or go wherever our interests lead us. By about 5th or 6th grade, we will start to gradually firm our program. But for now my primary goal is to ignite the spark!