Jump to content

Menu

Greenmama2

Members
  • Posts

    965
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by Greenmama2

  1. Ouch. That is awful :( I can understand why it is driving you crazy. Absolutely it is emotional abuse. You may find that CPS is able to help by requiring your sister to participate in mandatory counselling. At least, that would be a first step in this country.

    Is your BIL deployed? It sounds as though your sister could really use more time out to pull herself together. Is there any way your parents could pick the girls up from preschool and have them without your sister for a couple of hours one day a week? Both to build that sense of safe space for the girls but also for your sister to have time to prepare herself for mothering.

  2. We are struggling with science for my science-loving PKer. We are doing BFSU1 right now and expect to move onto BFSU2 sometime in 2014. I'm wondering if anyone has any suggestions for science curricula after BFSU for the accelerated, younger elementary set? I had planned to do Ellen McHenry's programs, followed eventually by CPO Science, but would this be appropriate? Thanks for any suggestions.

     

    Also, does anyone know where I can find a sequence for BFSU2 and 3?

    Hmm, BFSU really picks up the intensity in 2. I would not expect to move through it at the same pace. I love Ellen McHenry, but we have found her programs to fit well concurrently with BFSU 2, rather than following 3.
  3. Since he doesn't have a preference, do you have budget constraints? A piano would be a one-off expense (at least for a good number of years) but possibly a big one, a string instrument would be initially cheaper but he would need a new one every year or two as he grows (you can rent of course). What about carting it around? Will he need to carry it places himself as he gets older or will you be available to drive until he does? It isn't fun negotiating a bus with a tuba or double bass. Is he tall for his age? How long are his arms? What shape are his lips? Those can all influence choice of wind instrument.

    The instrument a child is most likely to succeed with is the one they have chosen themselves IMO. The best plan would be to start taking him to concerts, especially children's symphony performances & letting him get to know the instruments. Perhaps something will catch his fancy :)

  4. I think I have offended you. I certainly did not mean too, which is why I tried to clearly indicate that it depends on what your student needs/wants. Please know since you are new here, that there have been people who have posted here that *do* think that if your child *can*, then he *should*. Sometimes people just need to be reassured that very bright children do not have to do the same type of study as students who are much older.

     

    Ruth in NZ

    I started the seven year old thread, so I understand the need to ask. At five though we were still officially unschooling. That included plenty of academics because DD requested them. Technically we are still unschooling as everything "school" we do is something DD has asked for. Unschooling as a lifestyle suits our family a lot better than an structured approach, however I have found that DD needs clear cut time set aside in order to get the seatwork done that *she* wants to. This is something that has developed for her between six & seven so it's still new for me - hence needing to see how others approach it.

    At five we had no daily routine although I was trying desperately (&unsuccsefully) to insert some Waldorf style rhythm to our days. We did have a weekly schedule revolving around DDs dance classes, violin lessons and drama classes. That year DD did EPGY maths whenever she felt like it (which was often), SM whenever she liked (far less often), Mathletics (also whenever) ate up all the BFSU I could feed her and listened to as many read amours as her then 1 year old brother would let us get through. None of those things happened on any daily schedule however...

  5. I replied a few pages back with a general response, however I am married to an Australian (Tasmania). I read Deee's post and was sort of not familiar with ethnicity in that way. I have never ever even heard of 'skip' and so asked dh about it. He also had never heard of that. Is this a mainland term? We have been here (US) 16 years so maybe time has brought new words?

    We visit as often as possible, but we mostly just visit family, so may not have a great idea.

     

    Did someone mention 3rd culture identity? I heard about this about a year ago, and think that is what we have going on in our family. I have to look into that.

    Skip comes from Skippy the Kangaroo & is a derogatory term for "white Australians" used I'm response to being called "wog" "slanteye" etc. I don't think it was ever reclaimed to the extent that wog was and seems to have pretty much slipped from the vernacular since my childhood in the eighties.

    People with southern European heritage will still sometimes proudly call themselves wigs but I haven't heard anyone use skip for a long time.

  6. I replied a few pages back with a general response, however I am married to an Australian (Tasmania). I read Deee's post and was sort of not familiar with ethnicity in that way. I have never ever even heard of 'skip' and so asked dh about it. He also had never heard of that. Is this a mainland term? We have been here (US) 16 years so maybe time has brought new words?

    We visit as often as possible, but we mostly just visit family, so may not have a great idea.

     

    Did someone mention 3rd culture identity? I heard about this about a year ago, and think that is what we have going on in our family. I have to look into that.

    Skip comes from Skippy the Kangaroo & is a derogatory term for "white Australians" used I'm response to being called "wog" "slanteye" etc. I don't think it was ever reclaimed to the extent that wog was and seems to have pretty much slipped from the vernacular since my childhood in the eighties.

    People with southern European heritage will still sometimes proudly call themselves wigs but I haven't heard anyone use skip for a long time.

  7. You see, this situation I actually do understand: much of Britain is very culturally diverse with many first and second generation immigrants. What I'm trying to understand is people holding on to ethnic identities that are much further back in their past, where there are no lingering cultural or linguistic influences on them, but the origins matter nonetheless.

     

    L

    But that was the point of my first post & what a lot of other posters have been describing - that some aspects of culture and even language are still lingering after a long time (seven generations in my case).
  8. I also wanted to say that I agree with the PP that brought up the idea that it is difficult for someone from a culturally homogenous background to understand how identity works in a "melting pot/veggie soup/culturally diverse" region.

    I started primary school in Melbourne in 1981, 1/3 of my classmates had Italian parents and another 1/3 had Greek. Malaka was the first playground swear word I learnt. I had one Chinese friend which was unusual because most of the Asian kids (around another 1/5 of the school population) were refugees from Vietnam. My best friend was Indian. Well, so she strongly identified herself & so her physical appearance and dress marked her. Her father was a university professor and they followed his work to Germany when she was still a baby and stayed till she was five. Her first language was German, second was Hindi, third was a local Indian dialect and fourth was English which she spoke extremely well but with a heavy German accent. Her story wasn't hugely a unusual one among my classmates all through school. If you live now as an adult in the country your grandparents were born in, which is also the country most of your childhood friend's parent were born in, and your teachers parents and your co-workers great-grandparents etc then it must be difficult to understand why someone would even bother saying something other than "I am Australian" or "I am American" (the friend I mentioned had citizenship by the way, she could have said that too).

  9. What does it mean to me? Well it's hard to describe exactly what it means to me but it definitely means something strong. I am by a direct female line seventh generation Irish Australian. Seven generations is a very long time in a very young country yet because my great-great whatever Grandmother Brigit McNamara from County Clare settled in a particular part of this country, my own grandmother had an aunt and some cousins whose branch of the family were isolated enough that they spoke a Gaelic-English pidgeon (pidgen? Autocorrect insists on the bird). So my maternal family is still HUGELY influenced culturally by their Irish roots. My mother is actually the first to have left the region Brigit settled in. Add to that the history here of the persecution of Irish Catholics (anything more than a cursory Google on Ned Kelly will show you some of that) & you have a strong feeling of identification. That's without those feelings of "these are my people etc" I experienced when I started playing Irish music or learning a few words of Gaelic.

    Interestingly, despite all the above I wasn't aware just how much my family culture is "Irish" until I married DH who is first gen & his parents are "ten pound poms". He identifies completely as "Australian", yet we have discovered many areas where his upbringing has left him very British.

    Of course I would never claim to be Irish, I'm not. But I have a lot more in common culturally with my friends who are actually from Ireland than I do with DH who was born & raised in the same country as me.

  10. Maybe it means "This is a stupid question. I'm obviously here or I wouldn't be filling out this pain in the bum form."

     

     

    What isn't Australian? People without permanent residence or citizenship, I guess. 

     

     

     

    I'm a Caucasian Australian, though the important part for the statisticians is that I'm not of Aboriginal or Torres Strait Island descent. 

     

    Yes, I agree that is generally what they're asking. I much prefer it when they just have a check box for that.

  11. Hmmm...so how long do one's ancestors have to have lived in America before American becomes an ethnicity?  Is it just because we haven't been around long enough as a country?  How long before your Polish great-great-great-great grandmother who immigrated doesn't count anymore and you are officially "American"? 

     

    Won't America eventually develop its own ethncity?  And how long would that take?

     

    I find this stuff really interesting. Here we often have "Australian" as an option. WT does that mean? I'm seventh generation so anyone from Ireland would laugh at me if I said I was Irish, but I'm not "Australian" either :/

  12. And here's a nice, condescending reply for you.

     

    I'm so sorry your experiences in childhood were so unhelpful in training you to be a good parent. I think it's really sad you had no contact with kids until you had your own. Your life would have been so much richer for it. :crying:

     

     

     

    Did you see what I did there? I *assumed* a whole lot of things I had no right to assume, and I did it rudely.

     

     

     

    The OP has not claimed to know everything about parenting.

    The OP has stated that she has grown up with kids everywhere.

    One's ability to learn about children does not begin with delivery.

    For some people, having children is a steep learning curve, for others it feels like a continuation of what they've been learning their whole life.

    No young woman benefits from being scorned by her elders.

    Young women benefit from being invited to join the "grown ups" club.

    I "liked" this, but actually I love it <3

    mom2bee - here's a big cyberhug for you. Placing boundaries around family etc in neccessary in your 20s (imo) and also really, really hard.

×
×
  • Create New...