I'm stumped in trying to figure out the best Algebra 1 curriculum for my 8th grader. We've done a bit of a hodge podge over the past few years -- as we've tried some part-time school programs that included math. (They used McGraw Hill, and then Saxon pre-algebra - he HATED both). In the end, he basically completed at least 2 years of pre-algebra, including Jousting Armadillos, along with some basic Algebra I. I felt he needed some firming on concepts, so we've been working through the EPGY Grade 7 Redbird math, which I really like but which doesn't continue into Algebra.
I'd note that my son tends to test high on math, and to get concepts quickly. However, while he tends to get bored easily and hates to have things repeated, he also gets bogged down on details. He also has some learning differences that seem to make him freeze up when he confronts multi-step problem solving or anything he can't figure out in his head (though the calculations he can do that way often amaze me.)
For all of these reasons, I think AoPS is a bad idea. I guess I could just get the book, and we could work through it on our own pace, but I worry it will frustrate him. I also thought about the Jacobs book, which we got from the library, but the text-heavy pages freaked him out (he also has visual tracking issues, just to complicate things further.) He did like Jousting Armadillos and we started the Crocodile book, but understand from reading various posts here that we couldn't really use those books on their own.
The biggest issue is that he wants to work independently, and doesn't want a lot of input from me (he's 13 after all.) Redbird Math worked really well for him, since it was engaging and let him try problems several times until he got the right answer. Otherwise, he just clicks through to get finished quicker, even if he gets everything wrong. But the EPGY algebra comes from a different provider and is tutored, so very expensive.
My son is very interested in a career in science long-term, so I think a firm foundation in math is critical, but I just can't seem to find the right curriculum for next year. I'd really appreciate any suggestions!