Jump to content

Menu

shadah

Registered
  • Posts

    165
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by shadah

  1. White board worked best here. We keep all books in a bin. I have, at times, put sticky notes on each book, stacked their books at the table and said have at it. When they are done, they go back on the bin. Both are visual ways to track assignments.

  2. We were looking at a review of The Good and the Beautiful history course and dd noticed it comes with a game to review. I was wondering what other curriculum come with games or use games to teach. We thought of a few.

     

    Right Start

    SSRW

    AWOA

    Happy Phonics

    ?

  3. I downloaded several of the freebies and all of the samples. Reading through, possible cons would be the use of vintage books and the constant emphasis of "good." I like old books, no problem there. The "good" part of it can be preachy, but I guess no different than R&S, CLE, Abeka, or many CM currics. I can tune it out. I like the full color, the low price, and my daughter asks to do it. We are halfway through level 3 and going double speed. It covers things we would otherwise not get to like spelling and geography.

  4. Are you talking about history or language arts? If history - why is it the way you would design it? I'm having a hard time discerning from the samples if there are living books incorporated or just her overviews along with the other authors of the curriculum. I see books for reading challenges in the language arts but can't find that for history unless it's right in front of me and I'm missing it.

    Thanks!

    We are using the language arts. The history looks like it has vintage reprints in it. I don't see any extra reading. If I took the trouble to put a history program together I would have everything in audio, have a board game as a review option, and have different levels of assignments. She has all this in a three day a week schedule. I already have history covered, though. I haven't seen anything of hers I wouldn't try if it was a subject I needed. Have you written her? I often write and ask people why they wrote a curriculum a certain way. It helps when you can see what they were aiming for.

  5. Tam Tam is a phonics pre-course to Tamburin. You do basically a letter a week with a worksheet and activities. I used the activities only. They are reading fairly fluently by the end. Tamburin required reading but is still mostly game-based. The student makes the games themselves. They were easy to make - mostly index cards, dice, etc. The worksheets have a lot of cut and paste. Dd loved those.

    The only German book that has got any love here is Bobo Siebenschläfer. We have done better with cartoons and music in German.

  6. I use this in a weekly class. https://www.hueber.de/planetino/?id=pg_index_pli I order from Book Depository. It has songs and games. I add notebooking, more singing, board games, and active play. My kids are frustrated because it is too easy, but they like not being the only ones learning German. We don't have a Saturday school, so basically I made my own. I found it works better to teach children older than mine. The younger children in my classes have been slower to really speak German. The older kids are motivated to do things liks duolingo and watching movies on their own.

  7. I taught this class yesterday. It seems I was wrong again. The children I thought were five are seven. I just misjudged what a 7yo could be expected to do. If I teach again it will have to be middle schoolers.

    I have drastically cut down on content. I am working on skills as they come up. We spent class time yesterday on short vowels. It came up so I went with it. My children are no longer attending though.

    Next week we will be covering scissor skills so I can include cut and paste activities in place of much of the reading and writing. Neither of my kids is an auditory learner, so many of the ways to compensate are not things I am used to: more discussion, comparisons, activities, call and repeat, simon says, etc. To be honest, I feel silly but I am determined to make this work and teach to the best of my ability.

    By the way, MotherOf Boys, I like your siggy. I am also a planner who has learned to teach my children as they are. I am still too rigid in my planning for classes. I would have been better off seeing what I had first and then planning my semester. Lesson learned.

    • Like 1
  8.  

    Fwiw, many kids who aren't reading at a high level in 1st grade still end up as advanced students, so I am not sure you are on another planet so much as on a different path.

    Thank you. This helped me. I'm being too rigid in my thinking. I felt guilty for feeling frustrated. I can always stash my kids in other classes and work with what I ended up with in this class. It's just a different path.

    • Like 1
  9. I asked for 3-5th grades. I ended up having to accept 2nd and up. I thought it would be fine. Homework is copywork and memory work with some reading but not alot. I showed up the first day with a class of 5-6yos plus a few older ones who are unschoolers (noschoolers? Or at least very nontraditional).

    So, I am sitting here writing plans for what my kids could do at 5yo and that's not going to work either. I will figure the class out, but I think what really bothered me the most was the alien feeling. I have never dealt with this level of learning. I'm pulling notes of things I strewed when my oldest was two. I was on the phone this morning with a friend who has preschoolers trying to get a feel for how these ages and stages learn.

    I'm not expressing this well, I know. I'm not trying to be critical. I'm just baffled how to teach things it seems my kids were born with or learned while I wasn't looking.

    The upside of this is that my other class (planned for 3-5th grade as well) has 6-8th graders several of whom are likely smarter than I am. They are a wonderul challenge. I look forward to a rewarding semester and a good challenge for my kids.

    • Like 1
  10. I signed up to teach a co-op class this semester. I targeted the material at my 5yo. Prereqs for this class were 7yo, reading and writing on grade level. Apparently, I have no idea what a 7-10yos should be capable of. I had five units planned over fifteen weeks. That's one teaching week and two review weeks using games, books, active play, etc.

    Only one student can read at all. But, the problem is not just reading. My kids retain and use information. I don't see that happening with this class. We might be able to get through the first unit this semster if I break things down more and drill it to death.

    Sorry, I'm just venting. I'm stuck for this semester teaching. But, if I slow down and teach the class, my kids will be bored. If I teach at the level and pace I had planned, my kids will get it and the others will only have exposure?

    I thought my kids were ahead. I knew they think a little differently. I had no idea how differently. I feel like we are aliens and have landed on the wrong planet.

    • Like 4
  11.  

    • Which language(s), and how did/will you decide?

      We decided based on opportunities for that language.

    • When did/will you begin instruction--at what age (or other marker for readiness), and if more than one foreign language, when in relation to the first language did you start the second?

      German-from birth. We lived there then.

      Spanish-4yo We moved and had Spanish-speaking neighbors.

      Russian-7yo again neighbors. We choose to live in the city in a multilingual neighborhood even though we could live cheaper and in a larger house somewhere else.

      Latin and Greek-8yo local intro class and then interest-led at home. She hated the class but loved the languages. Basically, she told me she could do better by herself and I said prove it. She's doing great. Kid's are funny, aren't they?

    • When did/will you cease instruction, and what factors went/will go into your decision to stop?

      We haven't dropped any. Russian is for fun and could be dropped any time she wanted. Latin and Greek I made the rule that if I buy the course she finishes the course. German and Spanish she may drop when she goes to college.

    • If you have more than one child, did/will your children follow the same path?

      My 5yo has heard German from birth, chants Latin, and loves Spanish. He is not as language oriented and will probably do two maybe three and maybe on a slower progression. I realize my kids are still young and some of this is conjecture. So far, he has folded in on most of what she does. He listens, repeats, chants, watches cartoons, plays memory and headventureland. So, who knows?

    DD#1 loves Latin, and I love trying to figure out options and develop plans for the future (plans that are very much subject to change). So I'm just curious about how others approach language study in general. :)</p></p></p></p>
    We obviously love languages having lived overseas. I would first run through courses your library has. They are fun and no commitment. We did adult audio courses in the car and kids courses, videos, cds, etc. for school. That gave me a good idea what we liked and what we could do. I did not purchase a German course we committed to until last year. We did a little bit of everything and loved it that way. Dd is 8 and wants more organized goal-oriented learning so we have curriculum for everything except Russian. I can't fit it in as an "official" study so we just play with it - alphabet, songs, phrases.

    You know the only way to fail at a foreign language is to not do it.

    • Like 1
  12. My 8yo is doing duolingo. My 5yo is doing tinycards. It has the duolingo vocab but is a little easier to do. I type for him most of the time, though. As far as methods in general, immersion and tpr have been a total bust here. We tried for years. It was a complete waste of time. My kids are too literal. They want to understand everything right away. We use cartoons and songs for exposure but I have found little teaching value in it. In other words, don't limit yourself to children's language programs if your child doesn't think that way.

    • Like 2
  13. It's the colors that are distracting. We worked with lima beans for awhile because they are white. I have drooled over some natural wood manipulatives. But, it's just not practical. Her flashcards she wrote are black and white. Her drawings on her math papers are just in pencil. My explanations on the white board are in one color.

    I know this is weird, but I am kind of like this, too. I have a photographic memory for print. I can re-read books I have read before and play music. I can picture it in my head. I blank out if the page has color, though. She hasn't complained about that. But, I wonder if there is a connection. I didn't expect it in my kids. Look at all the money I wasted on cute kindergarten material and "fun" math. I have simplified since then and everything is going well except math. It's still a puzzle.

    Okay, now I'm embarrassed. I just told the world how weird we are. I have always looked at it like nothing really comes easy. A gift in one way is a curse in another.

×
×
  • Create New...