Hello,
I have a non-mathy 8th grader who is about 1/4 of the way through MUS Pre-Algebra. Hopefully he will finish over the summer so we can start Algebra.
MUS is working okay (better than Saxon was for him). We understand the explaination and I like the lesson, practice, review format. We are not making use of the blocks because using them doesn't seem to make any difference at all, although they are there when he feels like following along with the DVD. However, my son is still missing too many problems (as many as half). When he redoes the missed ones, he gets the answer correct on about half and then gets the rest when I sit down with him to work them. If he would work each problem twice the first time through, he would catch some of his mistakes. Half of the mistakes are due to the concept not being solidified.
I'm thinking of switching to Teaching Textbooks because of the dvd lessons and answers. I like the idea of him being able to pop in the answer dvd to see each problem worked out. This would eliminate the times when math doesn't get done because I haven't been available to go over it with him. (Hopefully).
But, this thought occured to me: Would watching the answer dvd just encourage passive learning? Would he check the workbook page, pop in the dvd to watch the answer, and then move on? I suppose I could require re-working first, then checking with the dvd. I guess my real question is this: Will TT help him be more successful in math than MUS? Will it enable him to be a more independant learner and not dependant on my schedule and availability? What about the neccessity for a computer? Would that keep him from moving forward on the days we have to take school work with us?
I'd like to hear from those of you who have used both programs. What were the advantages and disadvantages?
Wendy