I have a first grader who is doing well in spelling, writing, grammar, and reading (fluently at a 4th grade level) but really struggles with reading comprehension.
It does not seem to matter whether I read to her or she reads to me. It doesn't matter whether I am reading SOTW or science, or a fairy tale. She remember little details that she finds fascinating, but cannot answer basic questions about the important content in the story.
Her younger sister (by two years) usually listens in when I read aloud and she easily answers the questions. I am not sure exactly what the problem is or how to improve her comprehension. It does not seem to be an attention or discipline problem.
Any ideas?