...where would you recommend we live?
Background: I'm new to posting here, hi! I've got sons aged 12, 10, and 8. We've lived overseas since before they were born, and currently homeschool in a somewhat classical style. Kids are thriving academically but enrichment and social options are pretty limited, plus we'd like to be closer to family in the US. Hubs has a pretty portable job, and we're all US citizens; we're looking at Florida because of weather, taxes, and the hope of finding like-minded neighbors. These are our top considerations - do you live in a community that you think might be a good fit for us?
we're Catholic - a vibrant parish would be wonderful;
we're fairly conservative - but happy to just not talk politics if possible;
we're interested in a homeschooling community that offers lots of extracurriculars other than sports;
boys are currently interested in Dungeons and Dragons, robotics, history, fencing, piano;
we're considering sending kids to a brick-and-mortar high school, if there was a really excellent one available, especially a rigorous Catholic or classical option;
boys are all gifted, two highly, so acceleration/dual enrollment/enrichment options would be great;
welcoming community where you don't have to have lived there for 4 generations to make friends;
we're well enough off but not at all social climbers - I'd like to avoid a social scene where kids worry about their brand of sneakers and moms worry about their brand of purses;
kind of prefer suburbs over city or rural - a walkable neighborhood with sidewalks or cart paths would be ideal;
we've lived in hurricane zones before, and know about bugs and humidity, so no concerns there;
being within an hour of a beach would be a plus.
Keeping this a bit vague as we're not ready to announce a move, just starting to look into options. There was an older thread that was super helpful, and I'd love to hear some contemporary opinions. Thanks for any advice!