I really appreciate all of the suggestions so far--thank you! Of course, as an avid reader and teacher, I can see all of the beautiful qualities of TEWWG. I've taught the book for 3 consecutive years, and it just doesn't capture the students. I have them listen to the audio book narrated by Ruby Dee, which is immensely helpful, but so many of them just give up or don't care because they simply can't identify with any part of the book, story, or characters. I usually have about five out of each class that sticks with the book, and the others just don't bother or only skim sparknotes. My assessments are always higher-level questions and writing, so many end up doing poorly on the unit. I would really like to try something different next year just to change things up and see if I can get better engagement. This is the only book I have this problem with all year. The kids really get into studying Langston Hughes' poetry, art from the period, etc. but the book is just a no-win. I'm sure the demographics and local culture have a lot to do with it as well.