Jump to content

Menu

shell0830

Members
  • Posts

    45
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by shell0830

  1. I have done it twice now and we absolutely love it. Their book choices are fantastic and their activities are interesting and dynamic. We skipped a few activities here and there and I added a few things when we wanted to go deeper. I added math and handwriting but that was it. I don't agree with the authors that a standalone math program isn't needed.

    • Like 1
  2. Moving Beyond the Page 9-11 is a great curriculum for student-lead units. You can just buy a few lit units, a few social studies/science units or the whole program. We did 50 States and Poetry this year from the program and my 9 year old 4th grader loved them. We've done 8-10 lit units and they are parent-led but still very good quality.

  3. I countered these same feelings by using unit studies and lit unit based curriculum like Moving Beyond the Page and FIAR. I moved away from memory work and copy work in favor of more variety, creativity and fun. My oldest is 9, so I can't report back success with my method, but everyone really likes the approach here and they are learning a lot. The only thing I kept is the history cycle and SOTW although I alter and add to that even.

    Let us know if you switch what ends up working for you.

  4. I countered these same feelings by using unit studies and lit unit based curriculum like Moving Beyond the Page and FIAR. I moved away from memory work and copy work in favor of more variety, creativity and fun. My oldest is 9, so I can't report back success with my method, but everyone really likes the approach here and they are learning a lot. The only thing I kept is the history cycle and SOTW although I alter and add to that even.

    Let us know if you switch what ends up working for you.

  5. Moving Beyond the Page has a Poetry unit for ages 9-11 that my dd is enjoying. We are doing it for 3 weeks. It combines learning about poetic terms and writing poetry. It ends with a project of putting on a "poetry night" like a coffee shop.

  6. Yes to what the other posters have said. I truly do not expect my children, no matter how bright, to absorb what happened so long ago. It is so abstract to their little minds at that age. Laying a good foundation is important in these early years- they should understand differences now vs. in the recent and extreme past. They can understand basic timelines (cave dwellers, Ancients, medieval, Renaissance/explorers, modern in general). But they will hear year after year the ins and outs of histories and details. No need to rush it at this age. CHOW will likely interest her more when she's ready.

    Fwiw, I majored in history and I've learned more in 4 years of SOTW than I ever did in college. Trust me, your child will be happier just hearing the stories and absorbing what she hears over time than worrying about dates and names, and it will all come together when the lightbulb comes on and she makes connections.

  7. My schedule looked so similar to yours when I was first starting out. I quickly discovered what was really.important to cover and what could "fall off" with no problem. It is so exciting to plan it all out, but execution was entirely different (everything took so much longer than I thought!). I also learned along the way that my dd needed different materials than I thought she'd like/need, so I ended doing a lot of changing things up. We are all on a journey, and learning by doing is also what we parents need to do sometimes. If you discover you bit off more than you can chew, you can cut things back and change them to fit your needs. That's what I love about hs- flexibility.

  8. So far:

     

    Math: Teaching Textbooks 5

    Lit: CHOLLA for Ancients Logic stage and list of books to read

    Grammar: GWG Diagramming Guide

    Writing: IEW Ancients (but looking at everything else to compare right now)

    Spelling: SW E

    History: SOTW 1 (with 1st grade sis) and AG activities (paired by week w lit)

    Science: Equine Science by WP and 6 weeks of Human Anatomy & Phys (with emphasis on the book Care and Keeping of You)

    Logic: Mindbenders

    • Like 2
  9. I have a dd 9 with similar issues. I have a question: does this occur in math at all? My dd still writes numbers backwards and is resistant to write problems out in her workbook. She also physically has a handwriting issue (thumb over forefinger, fist grip, can't see her own stroke). Anyway, just curious if these issues all go together with other kids.

×
×
  • Create New...