Shurley GRAMMAR

[Coco_Clark]

Has anyone used the Shurley GRAMMAR program?  I'm deciding between that and the full Shurley English. I feel like it might be a better fit, as I really don't like the look of the Shurley writing.  

Or would I be better off just using Shurley English and skipping the day 5 writing?

This is for a 4th and 5th grader.  We would likely jump into Shurley 5, skip a year, and then do 7.  They've done Treasured Conversations for grammar in the past.

 

[PeterPan]

It has been a few years, but as I recall the writing was included in the normal Shurley levels. So on amazon it says Shurley Grammar, but the cover will say Shurley English Homeschooling and list a grade level. And yeah, just skip the writing if you want.

[knitgrl]

We use Shurley in 1st grade for one child. The grammar was fine, but I thought the writing expectations for a first grader were way out of line, so we skipped the writing bit. Not sure if the same would apply to higher levels.