Jump to content

Menu

Help please! I need help deciding between Logic of English Foundations and AAR!


Recommended Posts

Posted

I am desperately needing help deciding between LOE Foundations and AAR for my 6 year old. She hasn't had any formal phonics yet, but she can sound out some CVC words. I have read reviews for days on both and have read SO many great things about each program, that I'm having a really difficult time deciding between the two.

Any thoughts or advice?

Any input would be greatly appreciated!!

Posted

We haven't tried AAR, but we do have and love LOE.  When I was trying to make the decision it seemed to come down to does your child more likely to enjoy doing arts and crafts (cutting, coloring, etc..) or running across the room and grabbing the correct phonogram card, or jump up if you hear a long e but sit super still if you hear a short e, etc... My boys aren't the crafty type.  When I ask them to cut out and color something they consider it an evil form of punishment.  Therefore, we chose LOE.  

Posted (edited)

There is nothing in aar that needs to be colored. There are paper -based games, similar to file folder types of games. The cutting is not related to the concept being used. It can be done by the parent without losing anything from the child's learning. It doesn't have the large motor activities, but since the words and phonograms are already on cards, I found it very easy to add those myself. The other significant difference between the programs is that aar works on one sound of each phonogram at a time. Imo, this is a gentler way for a child to gain fluency. Loe has handwriting incorporated, but aar needs it added in. i think aar provides more material for gaining fluency, but I suppose you could just repeat things in loe to provide additional fluency practice.

 

Eta: My comments are referring to aar 1 and up. Aar pre is a bit different. I haven't used that one, but I believe there are craft pages for the letters in that level. That isn't how the regular levels are though.

Edited by Syllieann
  • Like 1
Posted

I don't think you can go wrong with either one, and like I said we have only used LOE.  I didn't mean to imply that AAR was only cutting and coloring because I really don't know.  It just seemed to me that when I was deciding which program to buy, it seemed like the can't sit still kids seemed to like LOE.  I have two can't sit still kids which is why we personally picked it.

 

I will say that I still look at the AAR readers and want them.  My oldest is now past them and I just can't justify the cost for one kid.  I will also say that the one thing I don't love about LOE is that it incorporates the writing.  My oldest wasn't ready for the writing, but didn't like that he was skipping it.  

Posted

I can't help with LOE, I ruled it out because I did not want anything to do with those accent marker things on the letters! I can give you a whole hearted endorsement of AAR. It's super easy to use and will teach your child to read fluently and well. My DS very quickly went from not even reading CVC words to reading anything in sight. It's really amazing! Don't worry about crafts, as said above its really more about quick cutting of paper for games. I did it for him when he was younger but now he does it quickly. He still enjoys the games and we are now halfway through AAR4. The other day he was playing with paper cut out donuts and having a blast. We do the lessons super quick now which we both like because he gets it but slower when he was just starting out so there's not a big time commitment. It still amazes me what can be accomplished by doing it about 15 min/day 4x week with lots of random time off. The readers are great. They are fun and have great illustrations and are not painful to listen to! Nothing like phonics readers at all. They also incorporate reading comprehension and parts of speech in a clever way which I hadn't expected. Yesterday he read a poem with perfect emphasis on the rhyming words which is all a credit to AAR and nothing I've done. I'm still amazed at how comprehensive it's turned out to be.

Posted

Wow! Thank you all for such great information and advice!! I so appreciate you all taking the time to give great feedback!

I think we will go with AAR. I feel that it will be a great fit for my daughter!

Thanks again!!!

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

×
×
  • Create New...