Jump to content

Menu

Horizons vs abeka math


3girls4me
 Share

Recommended Posts

Which of these do you think would be best for a child that is great at math? Breezes through lessons. Grasps concepts after having it explained once. Etc....

I will supplement with something like Math in Focus for word problems, but want to stick with one of these until perhaps 3rd or 4th grade.

Thanks!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

They're both solid courses. I've used both and prefer Horizons by far.

 

They're both colorful and spiral workbooks with perforated pages. They both add sprinkles of religion.

 

Abeka
-drills, drills, drills

-harsher with the piles of large problems

-2 pages, plus a drill or test daily

-has instruction right on the student page

-races through concepts and is nearly a full grade ahead by 4, then slows down and simmers awhile

 

Horizons

-keeps the sets more manageable

-has instruction right on the student page

-3 pages daily past the early levels (2 pages there), but the pages are more spread out and there's more workspace on the page

-has extra blackline review pages for new concepts in the TM

-"fun" bits in most lessons, like your answers will spell out a word, answer to a joke, or color in a picture

-*The biggest one IMO* - You can tell the author enjoys math!

-stealthily builds up the concepts and my kids have no idea how intense it has ramped up

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Honestly? Neither.

 

Neither is intended for a kid who grasps things the first time they are introduced if they are used exactly as is. You'll want to cut problems out, at the least, if you don't want your kid to be bored or frustrated. 

 

If you aren't afraid to cross problems off, move quickly through multiple lessons if they grasp the material, teach multiple lessons-worth-of-a-concept in one go, etc., then either will work just fine, but neither will be the 'best' for that kid. A more mastery type of math would be best for a kid who grasps things right away and doesn't need the constant review & spiraling that Horizons & Abeka give.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I have to disagree. :001_smile:  My 4th grader is a DC like the OP described. She is currently in Horizons 5 (book 2) and flies through a lesson in 20-30 minutes; occasionally she gets an itch and does multiple lessons in a day. Every problem of every lesson gets completed before she moves on. She's thriving and loves her Horizons books. :001_smile:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

My son is like that and is loving Abeka math k. He begs to do more pages, and we usually do 2 or more lessons a day. We just switched my oldest over to Abeka from Saxon because of the logical order of presentation of fact memorization and visual appeal.

 

I think either is good and will appeal to the child. A Beka does have a lot of work, but they have some of the review numbered in green, which is extra. It makes it easy to say do the black ones if they don't need the extra. But if they like to do more like my younger son, it is there. I especially like the challenge questions each day and the fact review games.

 

I considered both. My child preferred A Beka, but the main reason I chose A Beka was the teachers manual was more user friendly for me and laid out well. The Horizons teachers guide comes recommended, and if you don't like things laid out, you will do fine. It has game ideas, etc. But Horizons will say things like "review math facts" or Go over place value" and didn't give much direction in how to teach. Not having used it, I might have missed that there was more instruction somewhere else, and I probably could have handled the early grades. I do not plan to use A Beka beyond elementary, but it lays a very good foundation and rewards quick thinkers. However, ifyou are thinking of sticking with this longer term, Horizon has better reviews for the upper grades. But if you are using this more long term, the teachers guides are something to consider.

 

There are a lot of visual aids in A Beka. You do not need all of them (felt numbers are completely unnecessary,) but they can add up if you buy them all new. You can often find a lot of it on eBay. That is another consideration.

 

If you have a kid who loves doing math problems and does well with worksheets, either of these will be good.

 

This does not particularly concern me, but it does concern others. A Beka has no intention of caring about Common Core at all. Horizon does consider it, and is planning to take the standards into account into newer editions. It is not currently aligned. Again, I don't care one way or another as long as the product is good, but some do care about it.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

 Share

×
×
  • Create New...