What reading level is CHOW?

[midwestbelle]

Anyone know what reading level this is?

[JaneGrey]

According to this review, it is at an average 4th grade reading level: http://www.bellaonline.com/articles/art55685.asp

 

Another place says: "According to Mr. Hillyer, the purpose of this 'basal history study' for nine year olds is to 'have the pupil able to start with Primitive Man and give a summary of World History to the present time, with dates and chief events without prompting, questioning, hesitation, or mistake.'"http://homeschoolchristian.com/Reviews/HillyerHistoryoftheWorld.html

 

My oldest has been reading it.

[chiguirre]

It's used in Calvert's 4th grade and the student is expected to read it themself.

[TracyR]

Yep. Average 4th grade. The program is made for 4th graders. I'm always surprised to see families using it for children in K, 1, 2 grades. I think that 3rd is the lowest one should go. Because younger children cannot appreciate it or understand alot of it at a younger age.

[JaneGrey]

Well....My oldest is 6yo. He definitely can read it and understand it. I think it depends on a child's reading or comprehension level and not so much the age.

 

Even if a child cannot read it, he or she might still be able to comprehend it. Mom would know best. Wish I could find a sample of the text to show you.

 

Sometimes, I preview this and have him read it (just as I try to do with anything I give him to read independently). Then, we discuss it. Other times, I read it aloud to him and add my commentary as I see fit. I think we'd still be doing basically the same thing even if he were a 4th grader (by age) first reading CHOW.

 

We got CHOW because it was recommended by a private school teacher we respect. He was leading a free class this year and I couldn't pass on the opportunity. The class was geared to 3rd-6th graders, so we just tried it to see how it would work. The 6yo did just fine.

[midwestbelle]

my girls are 8 entering 3rd grade, they read about a grade level ahead. We will be using CHOW in SL core 2 this year and I wondered if it would be something we could take turns reading aloud.

 

I'll just have to try it out and see how it goes.

 

Thanks again

[abbeyej]

my girls are 8 entering 3rd grade, they read about a grade level ahead. We will be using CHOW in SL core 2 this year and I wondered if it would be something we could take turns reading aloud.

 

I think it would work well for that. The reading level shouldn't be a problem for them at all. My only concern would be that you'll want to read along and discuss it with them -- but that can be accomplished easily by having them take turns reading aloud.

[Plaid Dad]

I think it depends on a child's reading or comprehension level and not so much the age.

 

:iagree: Our dd used this last year; she was 6. She had no trouble comprehending it, but then, we also read it together and discussed it as we went along.