I spent quite a bit more time looking at the LLLotR samples today, and I'm more convinced that I want to do that program fully, so I think I have decided to put EIL off until 9th.
Dd isn't a fast reader and hasn't done much lit analysis before, aside from us just talking about books. She has done no writing about literature yet. I think that delving deep into LotR, a story she is already familiar with (and our whole family LOVES) will be a good introduction to lit analysis and writing. The program isn't heavy on writing, so I think we will still be able to work through another writing program too.
Also, since I have an issue with only planning on THREE books for lit over the entire year, I love your suggestion of reading Beowulf, Sir Gawain, etc. I was also thinking of adding an Arthurian legend as well....Can you recommend one? The three I see recommend the most are Pyle, Green , or White, but I am not familiar with any of them.
Thank you, Lori D, for your input. I'm really getting excited about using LLLotR next year!