I would also go with Kit, if that's the one she wants. Caroline is beautiful, and we actually bought her this past week - we took a trip to the AG store in Dallas. My dd5 decided on Caroline, and my dd9 went with Mckenna. I will say, I was super excited for Caroline, and we bought her tons of clothes; however, now that we have her, I sort of wish she went with another. The hair care is a bit much for my 5 year old with Caroline's long, curly hair. It doesn't tangle (or hasn't yet) but it certainly gets messed after she plays, and changes her clothes - or when she sleeps with her at night. When she gets ready to put her up, I have to spend about 20 minutes slowly wetting and brushing her hair back into barrel curls. She is very careful with her, so this isn't destructive or wild play - and her hair isn't crazy messed up - regular maintenance is definitely needed to maintain her hair. We've decided that Caroline will get a stand, and I'll order Kit to be the main doll she plays with, just until she just a bit older, and capable enough to manage Caroline's hair on her own. However, whichever she chooses, I'm sure she'll love.