We're doing C.C. this year, and my oldest turned 5 in October. We love it, but I really hate the cost. Seriously, the cost really turns me off. We're going to do it again next year, and I'll re-evaluate how I feel about it. I love the concept and the philosophy behind it. Young children are like sponges and they memorize things so easily. So it makes sense to take advantage of that and make them memorize things that aren't usually taught until middle or high school. And yes, it is just memorization and there is very little understanding. If we wait until they are in high school to teach the Periodic Table, it will be a totally new concept and it will be intimidating. But if they have already been introduced to it, and have memorized certain elements and their atomic numbers, it'll be a lot easier to go into more detail.
My daughter has memorized a lot from C.C. So don't underestimate a 5 year old. We don't even do C.C. everyday. Shoot! Some weeks we only do one day of memory work. But, we have the CD in the car and we listen to it over and over again. So even the weeks where we kind of slacked off are being reinforced.
Back to the price. It ends up costing me $500, plus $100 for my youngest to be in the nursery. So that's $600 just so we can attend. That's not including the books and timeline cards. Which, I'm really upset that after I spent $100 on the Veritas Press timeline cards and then laminated each one, that they are replacing them. Well, my feelings are actually bittersweet b/c I am excited about the new C.C. timeline cards. Now that there's not a copyright issue, songs and motions for the timeline cards can now be shared. But, had I known that they were going to replace them, I wouldn't have bought the current cards. They are not making people buy the new manual if they have the old manual, thank God! Anyway, so after timeline cards, we're up to almost $700. Then I need to buy the rest of my curriculum. My homeschooling cost easily reaches $1,000!!! I hate that! I love C.C. but I hate how much it's costing me! I don't want to quit, but I'm not rich! Just thinking about how much homeschooling's going to cost once my youngest begins...ugh!