This is only our second week of homeschooling, and the math program I was very excited to begin (Harcourt's "Math in Focus: The Singapore Approach") is not working out at all. My third grade son can do the problems easily, but the manner of doing the work is totally different from the way MiF wants him to do it. The whole program builds on working with number bonds in a specific way, and it is just not the way his brain works. My DH, a mental math whiz who never even used a calculator until pre-calculus, looked at the book today and says it makes things way too complicated.
DS attended ps for first and second grade, where they never had a math book, workbook, or program. All they did was worksheets, and at the end of the second grade year the most complex thing they were doing was two digit addition with regrouping. Despite this serious lack of structure, he does fine with more complex problems (we have been using Primary Grade Challenge Math and a couple of other fourth grade workbooks.)
I finally called my mom (2nd grade ps teacher) today in tears, and she told me to just find a basic math program that we could easily become familiar with and she would purchase it for us, as I have spent my entire curriculum fund for the year already. Nothing Singapore, although I love it and I think it would be a wonderful way to teach someone if you started at the beginning, nothing new or fancy. Just a well-established, tried-and-true math program. She thinks this will be a better transition from "here's a worksheet, that's all the math you get today" into an engaging homeschool math program that he will enjoy.
Should I just go with Saxon? There are two grade 3 Saxon texts, and the "intermediate" text does not offer a teacher's manual, is this a problem? Is there a better program? Thank you so much for any advice. It has just been an overwhelming day today, and not in a good way. I will learn and progress, I know. Homeschooling is still the best thing for our family, I will just have to do a lot of adjusting to get the proper fit.