So here is what we have and like:
The Real Mother Goose (it's OK)
Where the Sidewalk Ends, Shel Silverstein
Andrew Pudewa's Poetry Memorization - this is in our together time
We also read the poetry from the WYCNTK series 2-3x/week for youngers, 1x/week olders.
The Llama Who Had No Pajama (a favorite here - it came with a SL core)
A Child's Garden of Verse
What isn't a big hit:
Milne, just have never felt the love
A Family of Poems, not sure why, but it just isn't reached for
Rod and Staff Poems for Memorizing (May not be exact title) - I like these actually, it's sort of borderline, not really getting read though
When All the Stars Have Fallen (meh...not reached for, but it's a Canadian children's anthology, so...)
And a handful of other things that aren't substantial enough that I want to mention them.
Maybe I'm feeling the nudge into more meaty stuff for my oldest and a broader collection for my youngers.