@cintinative This post was almost 3 years ago. I would love to know what you have done and your opinion now. I am debating between Fix it Grammar (in second week of sample and my kids love, but not sure I want to commit to 6 years of grammar.) and Analytical Grammar. My 2 oldest that I am working with are almost 10 & 12 and struggling readers (finally getting it but weak for their ages) with little grammar exposure. But starting half way through 6th grade, Fix it Grammar would take the rest of my oldest schooling. Would I be better off doing Junior Analytical Grammar with both this spring and mechanics next fall and then start full Analytical Grammar with her mid-seventh. She could complete while still in middle school. But would she remember it, I don't think she would love it, but I like the quicker pace. Help!