My 9th grade daughter used Homeschool Spanish Academy last year. She enjoyed it but the end result was not pleasing to me in that she can still not carry on much of a conversation. Her tutoring focused more on memorizing words than conversing, although she did converse somewhat with her teacher. I know many people praise HSA, so maybe we just got the wrong teacher. Nevertheless, this year she is studying with Ray Leven online. Hopefully, that will be a better fit for her. Mr. Leven's class wasn't a good fit for my 7th grader this year. So, we are returning to ULAT and loving it. I tried ULAT when I had elementary students and it wasn't working, but this year it seems to be perfect. My 4th grader is using The Learnables. This is my first year using it, so I cannot give a solid review. Although, others have highly praised the program.